Center for Bioethics and Medical Humanities, Institute for Health & Equity, 5506Medical College of Wisconsin, Milwaukee, WI, USA.
Qual Health Res. 2023 Mar;33(4):259-269. doi: 10.1177/10497323231151816. Epub 2023 Jan 27.
The neonatal intensive care unit (NICU) is a morally charged space in which parents may be confronted with difficult decisions about the treatment of their newborns, decisions often complicated and created by the increasing use of technologies. This paper adopts a postphenomenological approach to explore the ethical consequences of technological mediation on parental treatment decision-making in the NICU. Semi-structured interviews were conducted with parents of children who received invasive technological support in the NICU to better understand how they made treatment decisions or decisions about specific interventions during their child's hospitalization. The findings suggest that technological mediation-or the various ways in which humans can interact with their world via technologies-contributes to experiences of ambiguity, ambivalence, and alienation in parental decision-making. The ambiguity of invasive NICU technologies can create uncertainty in a decision, which can then lead to internal ambivalence about which decision to make. Ultimately, this ambiguity and ambivalence may lead to alienation from one's child, as parents are disconnected physically and emotionally from the decision and thus their child. Articulating the effects of technological mediation on parental decision-making is a key step in addressing decisional conflict in neonatal intensive care settings and better supporting parents in their decision-making roles.
新生儿重症监护病房(NICU)是一个充满道德争议的地方,父母可能会在如何治疗新生儿的问题上面临艰难的决定,而这些决定往往因技术的广泛应用而变得复杂。本文采用后现象学方法探讨了技术中介对 NICU 中父母治疗决策的伦理后果。我们对在 NICU 中接受有创技术支持的儿童的父母进行了半结构化访谈,以更好地了解他们在孩子住院期间如何做出治疗决策或特定干预措施的决策。研究结果表明,技术中介——人类通过技术与世界互动的各种方式——导致父母决策中的模糊性、矛盾性和异化体验。有创性 NICU 技术的模糊性可能会导致决策的不确定性,从而导致对做出哪种决策的内部矛盾。最终,这种模糊性和矛盾可能导致父母与孩子的疏离,因为父母在身体和情感上与决策以及他们的孩子脱节。阐明技术中介对父母决策的影响是解决新生儿重症监护环境中决策冲突并更好地支持父母在其决策角色中的关键步骤。