Department of Psychology, Vanderbilt University, PMB 407817, 2301 Vanderbilt Place, Nashville, TN, 37240-7817, USA.
Department of Pathology, Microbiology and Immunology, Vanderbilt University, Nashville, USA.
Cogn Res Princ Implic. 2023 Feb 1;8(1):9. doi: 10.1186/s41235-022-00456-9.
We investigated the relationship between category learning and domain-general object recognition ability (o). We assessed this relationship in a radiological context, using a category learning test in which participants judged whether white blood cells were cancerous. In study 1, Bayesian evidence negated a relationship between o and category learning. This lack of correlation occurred despite high reliability in all measurements. However, participants only received feedback on the first 10 of 60 trials. In study 2, we assigned participants to one of two conditions: feedback on only the first 10 trials, or on all 60 trials of the category learning test. We found strong Bayesian evidence for a correlation between o and categorisation accuracy in the full-feedback condition, but not when feedback was limited to early trials. Moderate Bayesian evidence supported a difference between these correlations. Without feedback, participants may stick to simple rules they formulate at the start of category learning, when trials are easier. Feedback may encourage participants to abandon less effective rules and switch to exemplar learning. This work provides the first evidence relating o to a specific learning mechanism, suggesting this ability is more dependent upon exemplar learning mechanisms than rule abstraction. Object-recognition ability could complement other sources of individual differences when predicting accuracy of medical image interpretation.
我们研究了类别学习与广义物体识别能力(o)之间的关系。我们在放射学背景下评估了这种关系,使用类别学习测试,参与者判断白细胞是否癌变。在研究 1 中,贝叶斯证据否定了 o 和类别学习之间的关系。尽管所有测量的可靠性都很高,但这种相关性仍然不存在。然而,参与者只在 60 次试验中的前 10 次收到反馈。在研究 2 中,我们将参与者分配到两种条件之一:仅在前 10 次试验中反馈,或在类别学习测试的所有 60 次试验中反馈。我们发现,在全反馈条件下,o 与分类准确性之间存在强烈的贝叶斯证据相关,但在反馈仅限于早期试验时则不存在。中等程度的贝叶斯证据支持这些相关性之间的差异。没有反馈,参与者可能会坚持他们在类别学习开始时制定的简单规则,那时试验更容易。反馈可能会鼓励参与者放弃不太有效的规则,并转向范例学习。这项工作首次提供了将 o 与特定学习机制联系起来的证据,表明这种能力更多地依赖于范例学习机制,而不是规则抽象。物体识别能力可以在预测医学图像解释的准确性时补充其他个体差异来源。