School of Environment, Tsinghua University, Beijing, 100084, China; Center for Ecological Civilization, Tsinghua University, Beijing, 100084, China.
Yangtze Delta Region Institute of Tsinghua University, Jiaxing, 314006, China.
J Environ Manage. 2023 Apr 15;332:117302. doi: 10.1016/j.jenvman.2023.117302. Epub 2023 Feb 1.
The EU Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM) is regarded as the world's first carbon tariff regulation. Its consequential impacts on the trades of individual countries/regions at different development stages are crucial for climate justice while remaining unclear. By combining Multi-regional Input-output analysis and scenario analysis, this study analyzed the economic-carbon inequality in national/regional plastic exports and simulated CBAM's short-term impacts on plastic trade inequality under different scenarios. Our analysis shows that the maximum values of total carbon tariffs for all countries/regions levied on plastic exports to the EU will be 497.8, 859.1, and 1564.2 million euros under scenarios covering Scope 1, Scope 1&2, and Scope 1&2&3 emissions, respectively. The corresponding proportions of CBAM costs to national/regional plastic export volumes to the EU will be 0.6%, 1.0%, and 1.8% on average, respectively. China and the rest of Asia and the Pacific will burden the most CBAM costs in all cases, and Russia will be the country most affected. CBAM will exacerbate the economic-carbon inequality in the plastic trade by reducing the trade profits of developing economies with higher ratios than those of developed economies. Our analysis calls for practical initiatives to induce technological advances toward lower carbon technologies, increase trade diversification, exploit the domestic market's potential, and implement domestic carbon pricing mechanisms to alleviate the negative impact of CBAM.
欧盟碳边境调整机制(CBAM)被视为全球首个碳关税法规。其对不同发展阶段的个别国家/地区贸易的影响对于气候正义至关重要,但仍不清楚。本研究结合多区域投入产出分析和情景分析,分析了国家/地区塑料出口的经济-碳不平等,并模拟了 CBAM 在不同情景下对塑料贸易不平等的短期影响。分析结果表明,在涵盖范围 1、范围 1&2 和范围 1&2&3 排放的情景下,所有国家/地区对向欧盟出口塑料征收的总碳关税的最大值将分别为 4.978 亿欧元、8.591 亿欧元和 15.642 亿欧元。相应的 CBAM 成本占国家/地区向欧盟出口塑料量的比例将分别平均为 0.6%、1.0%和 1.8%。在所有情况下,中国和亚太其他地区将承担最多的 CBAM 成本,而俄罗斯将受到最大的影响。CBAM 将通过减少具有较高碳强度比的发展中经济体的贸易利润,加剧塑料贸易的经济-碳不平等,而发达国家的碳强度比则较低。我们的分析呼吁采取实际举措,推动向低碳技术的技术进步,增加贸易多样化,挖掘国内市场潜力,并实施国内碳定价机制,以减轻 CBAM 的负面影响。