Cundiff David K
Internal Medicine and Global Health, Independent Medical Researcher, California, USA.
Cureus. 2023 Jan 2;15(1):e33253. doi: 10.7759/cureus.33253. eCollection 2023 Jan.
Aim and background This article aims to link early deaths due to diet-related noncommunicable diseases at the global level, low animal food intake, primarily in developing countries, regenerative/organic agriculture, worldwide food security, and global warming mitigation. On statistically modeling Global Burden of Disease (GBD) risk factor and health outcome data, the unexpected finding was that early deaths (death before age 70) per year per 100k population due to noncommunicable diseases (NCDs, such as coronary artery disease, emphysema, liver failure, kidney failure, and cancers) were much higher in cohorts with low consumption of animal-sourced foods (processed meat, red meat, dairy, fish, poultry, eggs, and saturated fats). Relatively low NCD rates are associated with high animal food consumption. This unexpected finding led to exploring the implications of climate change. Methods I critiqued the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change's (IPCC's) definitions of "sustainability in land management, sustainable intensification (of agriculture), climate-smart agriculture," and "sustainability-focused socioeconomic pathway 1 (SSP1)"-the most climate-favorable scenario that the IPCC modeled. I modeled doubling the global livestock together with global regenerative/organic agriculture compared with the IPCC's SSP1, using the IPCC's mean 2010-2019 global anthropogenic greenhouse gas emissions (GHGs) as the baseline for comparison. Results This study found that all the IPCC's agricultural land-related definitions of interest were aspirational without detailing the farming methods used and those not allowed. The IPCC's land management-related definitions differed from the same or similar terms in the literature. The status quo net global agriculture and other land use GHGs (2010-2019) totaled 11.9 ± 4.4 gigatonnes (GT) carbon dioxide equivalent per year (11.9 ± 4.4 GTCO-eq yr). The IPCC's modeling of the SSP1 scenario reduced GHGs to 3 GTCO-eq yr by 2050. Transitioning to global regenerative/organic agriculture (5 billion hectares) and doubling the global livestock for human consumption and agricultural land fertilization corresponded to net global GHGs = -24.1 GTCO-eq yr for 2-3 decades, totaling -482 to -723 GTCO-eq of CO sequestration. Conclusions Doubling global livestock combined with worldwide regenerative/organic agriculture has the potential to mitigate climate change significantly more than SSP1 while providing global food security by reversing land degradation. Worldwide transitioning from intensive industrial agriculture that degrades land to regenerative/organic agriculture that sequesters CO in soil and doubling global livestock would require initial support with finances, resources, and additional workers for farms in both developing and developed countries. Subsequently, farms and farmers would be sustainably self-supporting with food sales. Retaining the existing farm workers and attracting hundreds of millions more workers would likely require transitioning most agricultural lands into worker-owned cooperatives.
目的与背景 本文旨在将全球层面与饮食相关的非传染性疾病导致的过早死亡、主要在发展中国家的低动物食品摄入量、再生/有机农业、全球粮食安全以及缓解全球变暖联系起来。在对全球疾病负担(GBD)风险因素和健康结果数据进行统计建模时,意外发现是,动物源性食品(加工肉类、红肉、乳制品、鱼类、家禽、蛋类和饱和脂肪)消费量低的人群中,每10万人口每年因非传染性疾病(如冠状动脉疾病、肺气肿、肝衰竭、肾衰竭和癌症)导致的过早死亡(70岁前死亡)要高得多。相对较低的非传染性疾病发病率与高动物食品消费量相关。这一意外发现促使人们探讨气候变化的影响。
方法 我批评了政府间气候变化专门委员会(IPCC)对“土地管理中的可持续性、(农业的)可持续集约化、气候智能型农业”以及“以可持续性为重点的社会经济途径1(SSP1)”的定义——这是IPCC建模的最有利于气候的情景。我以IPCC 2010 - 2019年全球人为温室气体排放平均值为比较基线,对全球牲畜数量翻倍以及全球再生/有机农业进行了建模,并与IPCC的SSP1进行比较。
结果 本研究发现,IPCC所有与农业用地相关的感兴趣定义都只是理想目标,没有详细说明所使用的耕作方法和不允许的方法。IPCC与土地管理相关的定义与文献中的相同或类似术语不同。2010 - 2019年全球农业和其他土地利用温室气体现状净值总计为每年11.9±4.4吉吨(GT)二氧化碳当量(11.9±4.4 GTCO₂-eq/yr)。IPCC对SSP1情景的建模到2050年将温室气体减少到3 GTCO₂-eq/yr。向全球再生/有机农业(50亿公顷)转型并使供人类消费和农业土地施肥的全球牲畜数量翻倍,在2 - 3十年间全球温室气体净值为-24.1 GTCO₂-eq/yr,总共封存-482至-723 GTCO₂-eq的碳。
结论 全球牲畜数量翻倍并结合全球再生/有机农业,有可能比SSP1更显著地缓解气候变化,同时通过扭转土地退化来保障全球粮食安全。全球从使土地退化的集约化工业农业向能在土壤中封存碳的再生/有机农业转型,并使全球牲畜数量翻倍,这需要在资金、资源和额外劳动力方面对发展中国家和发达国家的农场提供初步支持。随后,农场和农民将通过食品销售实现可持续的自我维持。保留现有农场工人并吸引数亿更多工人,可能需要将大多数农业土地转变为工人所有的合作社。