TECNALIA, Basque Research & Technology Alliance (BRTA), Derio, Spain.
DeustoPsych, Assessment, Clinical and Health, Faculty of Health Sciences, University of Deusto, Bilbao, Spain.
PLoS One. 2023 Feb 7;18(2):e0281534. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0281534. eCollection 2023.
A methodological proposal of a scale for human perception assessment of acoustic environment (acoustic comfort) in urban public spaces is presented: Acoustic Comfort Assessment Scale (ACAS 12). This paper shows the process of constructing this scale and its psychometric properties and validation. The approach is based on the soundscape conceptualisation collected in ISO 12913-1:2014 (Acoustics-Soundscape: Definition and conceptual framework). The proposed scale is a 5-point semantic differential scale made up of twelve pairs of bipolar adjectives, grouped around five theoretical dimensions. It is based on previous versions of 2-point and 3-point scales. The ACAS-12 scale is the result of several empirical studies carried out by the authors on environmental and acoustic comfort assessment, beginning in 2011 in some cities of the Basque Country (Spain). Selected urban open places cover a wide variability of acoustic and non-acoustic characteristics, as well as the type of participants (real users) and activities carried out in these places. The original language of this scale is Spanish. The back-translation technique has been applied to create the English version. The results highlight the good psychometric properties of the ACAS 12 scale (Cronbach's alpha 0.91 and composite reliability 0.90) and indicate that the best factorial solution is that of a single factor composed of the 12 pairs of adjectives that would explain approximately 50% of the ACAS-12 variance (44% of extracted variance by Raykov's method or 56% by the MAP test). The absolute and incremental fit indices were above the minimum reference value of 0.90 and the residual-based indices showed values close to suitability (SRMR = 0.057; RMSEA = 0.042). This result supports the consideration of the ACAS-12 scale as a general measure of acoustic comfort.
本文提出了一种用于评估城市公共空间声环境(声学舒适度)的人类感知评估量表的方法学建议:声学舒适度评估量表(ACAS 12)。本文展示了构建该量表及其心理测量特性和验证的过程。该方法基于 ISO 12913-1:2014(声学-景观:定义和概念框架)中收集的景观声音概念。所提出的量表是一个由 12 对两极形容词组成的 5 点语义差异量表,围绕五个理论维度分组。它是基于先前的 2 点和 3 点量表版本。ACAS-12 量表是作者在环境和声学舒适度评估方面进行的多项实证研究的结果,始于 2011 年在西班牙巴斯克地区的一些城市。所选的城市开放空间涵盖了广泛的声学和非声学特征,以及参与者的类型(实际使用者)和在这些地方进行的活动。该量表的原始语言是西班牙语。应用回译技术创建了英文版本。结果突出了 ACAS 12 量表良好的心理测量特性(Cronbach 的 alpha 为 0.91,综合可靠性为 0.90),并表明最佳的因子解决方案是由 12 对形容词组成的单一因子,这将解释大约 50%的 ACAS-12 方差(Raykov 方法提取的方差的 44%或 MAP 测试的 56%)。绝对和增量拟合指数均高于 0.90 的最低参考值,基于残差的指数值接近适宜性(SRMR=0.057;RMSEA=0.042)。该结果支持将 ACAS-12 量表视为声学舒适度的一般衡量标准。