School of Public Health, Boston University, Boston, USA.
World Health Organization Eastern Mediterranean Regional Office, Health Emergencies Programme, Cairo, Egypt.
J Epidemiol Glob Health. 2023 Mar;13(1):105-114. doi: 10.1007/s44197-023-00091-7. Epub 2023 Feb 9.
World Health Organization Eastern Mediterranean Region (WHO EMR) has 40% people in the world in need of humanitarian assistance. This systematic review explores selected vector-borne and zoonotic diseases (VBZDs) of importance to EMR in terms of disease burden across countries and periods, disaggregated across sex, age groups, education levels, income status, and rural/urban areas, related vector or animal source reduction measures, and public health, social and economic impacts and related interventions.
We used the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) guidelines and reviewed articles in PubMed, Embase, and WHO Global Index Medicus published between 1st of January 2011 and 27th of June 2022. Thirteen VBZDs with at least one reported outbreak in the last five years in the region or prioritized as per previous analysis at the WHO global and regional level and based on expert consultations, were included as part of the analysis.
The review included 295 studies-55% on leishmaniasis and dengue combined, and 75% studies from Pakistan, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, and Iran combined. Hospital-based and nationally representative studies constituted 60% and 10% respectively. Males were predominantly affected in most diseases; children reported high burden of Leishmaniasis, whereas elderly had a higher burden of Dengue Fever and Middle East Respiratory Syndrome. Although very few studies reported on socioeconomic differences in burden, the ones that reported showed higher burden of diseases among the disadvantaged socioeconomic groups such as the poor and the less educated. More than 80% studies reported an increase in burden over the years.
The literature is scanty for most of the diseases reviewed and the number of studies from countries with humanitarian challenges is very low. The need for more nationally representative, population-based studies calls for prioritizing research investments.
世界卫生组织东地中海区域(WHO EMR)有 40%的世界人口需要人道主义援助。本系统评价从疾病负担、性别、年龄组、教育水平、收入状况、城乡地区、相关病媒或动物源减少措施以及公共卫生、社会和经济影响及相关干预措施等方面,探讨了对 EMER 具有重要意义的选定虫媒和动物源性疾病(VBZDs)。
我们使用了系统评价和荟萃分析的首选报告项目(PRISMA)指南,并在 PubMed、Embase 和世界卫生组织全球索引医学杂志上检索了 2011 年 1 月 1 日至 2022 年 6 月 27 日期间发表的文章。该区域在过去五年内至少有一次报告暴发的 13 种 VBZDs 或根据之前在全球和区域层面的世卫组织分析以及专家协商被列为优先事项,被纳入分析。
该评价纳入了 295 项研究-55%的研究是关于利什曼病和登革热的综合研究,75%的研究来自巴基斯坦、沙特阿拉伯王国和伊朗三国的综合研究。基于医院的研究和全国代表性研究分别占 60%和 10%。大多数疾病中男性受影响居多;儿童报告了利什曼病的高负担,而老年人则报告了登革热和中东呼吸综合征的高负担。尽管很少有研究报告疾病负担在社会经济方面的差异,但有报告的研究表明,疾病负担在贫困和受教育程度较低等社会经济弱势群体中较高。超过 80%的研究报告称,多年来疾病负担有所增加。
大多数被审查的疾病文献很少,而且来自人道主义挑战国家的研究数量非常低。需要更多的全国代表性、基于人群的研究,呼吁优先投资研究。