Buxton R, Grennan D M, Palmer D G
Curr Med Res Opin. 1978;5(9):682-7. doi: 10.1185/03007997809110207.
A double-blind, crossover clinical trial was carried out with a new propionic acid derivative, fenbufen, versus indomethacin and placebo in 20 patients with osteoarthrosis. Active drug dosages of 75 mg indomethacin daily and 600 mg fenbufen daily were used. Fenbufen scored significantly better than placebo with respect to two and indomethacin better than placebo with respect to five of the assessment indices used. Indomethacin was significantly better than fenbufen with respect to two indices and, overall, appeared more effective in the dosages tested. Biochemical abnormalities of liver function (serum alkaline phosphatase and/or SGOT) were noted in 5 patients after fenbufen therapy (in 3 patients after 4-weeks' treatment and in 2 after 6 weeks) but in none after indomethacin therapy. The significance of these findings is discussed. It is concluded that fenbufen should be withdrawn from further clinical use until the true incidence and significance of hepatotoxicity has been evaluated.
对20例骨关节炎患者进行了一项双盲交叉临床试验,比较一种新的丙酸衍生物芬布芬与吲哚美辛及安慰剂的疗效。使用的活性药物剂量为每日75毫克吲哚美辛和每日600毫克芬布芬。在所使用的评估指标中,芬布芬在两项指标上的得分显著高于安慰剂,吲哚美辛在五项指标上的得分高于安慰剂。在两项指标上,吲哚美辛显著优于芬布芬,总体而言,在所测试的剂量下,吲哚美辛似乎更有效。芬布芬治疗后,5例患者出现肝功能生化异常(血清碱性磷酸酶和/或谷草转氨酶)(3例在治疗4周后,2例在治疗6周后),但吲哚美辛治疗后无1例出现异常。对这些发现的意义进行了讨论。结论是,在肝毒性的真实发生率和意义得到评估之前,应停止芬布芬的进一步临床应用。