药物过量警报和响应技术:最新综述。
Overdose Alert and Response Technologies: State-of-the-art Review.
机构信息
DigitAS, Populations and Behavioural Science Division, School of Medicine, University of St Andrews, St Andrews, Fife, United Kingdom.
Salvation Army Centre for Addiction Services, Faculty of Social Sciences, University of Stirling, Stirling, United Kingdom.
出版信息
J Med Internet Res. 2023 Feb 15;25:e40389. doi: 10.2196/40389.
BACKGROUND
Drug overdose deaths, particularly from opioids, are a major global burden, with 128,000 deaths estimated in 2019. Opioid overdoses can be reversed through the timely administration of naloxone but only if responders are able to administer it. There is an emerging body of research and development in technologies that can detect the early signs of an overdose and facilitate timely responses.
OBJECTIVE
Our aim was to identify and classify overdose-specific digital technologies being developed, implemented, and evaluated.
METHODS
We conducted a "state-of-the-art review." A systematic search was conducted in MEDLINE, Embase, Web of Science, Scopus, ACM, IEEE Xplore, and SciELO. We also searched references from articles and scanned the gray literature. The search included terms related to telehealth and digital technologies, drugs, and overdose and papers published since 2010. We classified our findings by type of technology and its function, year of publication, country of study, study design, and theme. We performed a thematic analysis to classify the papers according to the main subject.
RESULTS
Included in the selection were 17 original research papers, 2 proof-of-concept studies, 4 reviews, 3 US government grant registries, and 6 commercial devices that had not been named in peer-reviewed literature. All articles were published between 2017 and 2022, with a marked increase since 2019. All were based in or referred to the United States or Canada and concerned opioid overdose. In total, 39% (9/23) of the papers either evaluated or described devices designed to monitor vital signs and prompt an alert once a certain threshold indicating a potential overdose has been reached. A total of 43% (10/23) of the papers focused on technologies to alert potential responders to overdoses and facilitate response. In total, 48% (11/23) of the papers and 67% (4/6) of the commercial devices described combined alert and response devices. Sensors monitor a range of vital signs, such as oxygen saturation level, respiratory rate, or movement. Response devices are mostly smartphone apps enabling responders to arrive earlier to an overdose site. Closed-loop devices that can detect an overdose through a sensor and automatically administer naloxone without any external intervention are still in the experimental or proof-of-concept phase. The studies were grouped into 4 themes: acceptability (7/23, 30%), efficacy or effectiveness (5/23, 22%), device use and decision-making (3/23, 13%), and description of devices (6/23, 26%).
CONCLUSIONS
There has been increasing interest in the research and application of these technologies in recent years. Literature suggests willingness to use these devices by people who use drugs and affected communities. More real-life studies are needed to test the effectiveness of these technologies to adapt them to the different settings and populations that might benefit from them.
背景
药物过量死亡,尤其是阿片类药物过量死亡,是一个全球性的重大负担,据估计,2019 年有 12.8 万人死亡。通过及时给予纳洛酮,阿片类药物过量可以逆转,但前提是响应者能够给予纳洛酮。目前,已经有越来越多的技术研究和开发,可以检测到药物过量的早期迹象,并促进及时响应。
目的
我们的目的是识别和分类正在开发、实施和评估的特定于药物过量的数字技术。
方法
我们进行了“最新技术综述”。在 MEDLINE、Embase、Web of Science、Scopus、ACM、IEEE Xplore 和 SciELO 中进行了系统搜索。我们还查阅了文章中的参考文献,并扫描了灰色文献。搜索包括与远程医疗和数字技术、药物和药物过量相关的术语,以及自 2010 年以来发表的论文。我们根据技术类型及其功能、发表年份、研究国家、研究设计和主题对我们的发现进行了分类。我们对论文进行了主题分析,根据主要主题对其进行了分类。
结果
入选的包括 17 篇原始研究论文、2 项概念验证研究、4 篇综述、3 份美国政府资助登记处和 6 种尚未在同行评议文献中命名的商业设备。所有文章均发表于 2017 年至 2022 年之间,自 2019 年以来明显增加。所有文章均基于或涉及美国或加拿大,且均与阿片类药物过量有关。总的来说,39%(9/23)的论文评估或描述了设计用于监测生命体征并在达到潜在药物过量的某个阈值时发出警报的设备。总共 43%(10/23)的论文侧重于向潜在的药物过量响应者发出警报并促进响应的技术。总共 48%(11/23)的论文和 67%(4/6)的商业设备描述了组合警报和响应设备。传感器监测一系列生命体征,例如血氧饱和度水平、呼吸频率或运动。响应设备主要是智能手机应用程序,使响应者能够更早地到达药物过量地点。可以通过传感器检测到药物过量并自动给予纳洛酮而无需任何外部干预的闭环设备仍处于实验或概念验证阶段。研究分为 4 个主题:可接受性(7/23,30%)、疗效或有效性(5/23,22%)、设备使用和决策(3/23,13%)和设备描述(6/23,26%)。
结论
近年来,人们对这些技术的研究和应用越来越感兴趣。文献表明,吸毒者和受影响社区愿意使用这些设备。需要更多的真实生活研究来测试这些技术的有效性,以使其适应可能受益于这些技术的不同环境和人群。