Husain Mouzzam, Simpkin Andrew, Gibbons Claire, Talkar Tanya, Low Daniel, Bonato Paolo, Ghosh Satrajit S, Quatieri Thomas, O'Keeffe Derek T
Health Innovation Via Engineering (HIVE) Lab, Curam, Lero, School of MedicineLambe Institute for Translational ResearchNational University of Ireland Galway H91 TK33 Galway Ireland.
School of Mathematics, Statistics and Applied MathematicsNational University of Ireland H91 TK33 Galway Ireland.
IEEE Open J Eng Med Biol. 2022 Feb 14;3:235-241. doi: 10.1109/OJEMB.2022.3143688. eCollection 2022.
Official tests for COVID-19 are time consuming, costly, can produce high false negatives, use up vital chemicals and may violate social distancing laws. Therefore, a fast and reliable additional solution using recordings of cough, breathing and speech data for preliminary screening may help alleviate these issues. This scoping review explores how Artificial Intelligence (AI) technology aims to detect COVID-19 disease by using cough, breathing and speech recordings, as reported in the literature. Here, we describe and summarize attributes of the identified AI techniques and datasets used for their implementation. A scoping review was conducted following the guidelines of PRISMA-ScR (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses Extension for Scoping Reviews). Electronic databases (Google Scholar, Science Direct, and IEEE Xplore) were searched between 1st April 2020 and 15th August 2021. Terms were selected based on the target intervention (i.e., AI), the target disease (i.e., COVID-19) and acoustic correlates of the disease (i.e., speech, breathing and cough). A narrative approach was used to summarize the extracted data. 24 studies and 8 Apps out of the 86 retrieved studies met the inclusion criteria. Half of the publications and Apps were from the USA. The most prominent AI architecture used was a convolutional neural network, followed by a recurrent neural network. AI models were mainly trained, tested and run-on websites and personal computers, rather than on phone apps. More than half of the included studies reported area-under-the-curve performance of greater than 0.90 on symptomatic and negative datasets while one study achieved 100% sensitivity in predicting asymptomatic COVID-19 from cough-, breathing- or speech-based acoustic features. The included studies show that AI has the potential to help detect COVID-19 using cough, breathing and speech samples. The proposed methods (with some time and appropriate clinical testing) could prove to be an effective method in detecting various diseases related to respiratory and neurophysiological changes in the human body.
新冠病毒(COVID-19)的官方检测耗时、成本高,可能产生高假阴性结果,会耗尽重要化学试剂,还可能违反社交距离规定。因此,一种快速可靠的额外解决方案,即使用咳嗽、呼吸和语音数据记录进行初步筛查,可能有助于缓解这些问题。本综述探讨了人工智能(AI)技术如何旨在通过使用文献中报道的咳嗽、呼吸和语音记录来检测新冠病毒疾病。在此,我们描述并总结了已识别的用于其实施的AI技术和数据集的属性。按照PRISMA-ScR(系统评价和Meta分析扩展的范围综述的首选报告项目)的指南进行了范围综述。在2020年4月1日至2021年8月15日期间搜索了电子数据库(谷歌学术、科学Direct和IEEE Xplore)。基于目标干预(即AI)、目标疾病(即COVID-19)以及该疾病的声学关联(即语音、呼吸和咳嗽)选择了检索词。采用叙述性方法总结提取的数据。在检索到的86项研究中,有24项研究和8个应用程序符合纳入标准。一半的出版物和应用程序来自美国。使用最突出的AI架构是卷积神经网络,其次是循环神经网络。AI模型主要在网站和个人电脑上进行训练、测试和运行,而不是在手机应用程序上。超过一半的纳入研究报告称,在有症状和阴性数据集上曲线下面积性能大于0.90,而一项研究在从基于咳嗽、呼吸或语音的声学特征预测无症状COVID-19方面达到了100%的敏感性。纳入的研究表明,AI有潜力通过使用咳嗽、呼吸和语音样本帮助检测COVID-19。所提出的方法(经过一些时间和适当的临床测试)可能被证明是检测与人体呼吸和神经生理变化相关的各种疾病的有效方法。