Department of Medical Psychology, Amsterdam UMC, University of Amsterdam, Meibergdreef 9, PO Box 22660, 1100 DD, Amsterdam, The Netherlands.
Quality of Care Program, Amsterdam Public Health Research Institute, Amsterdam, The Netherlands.
Support Care Cancer. 2023 Feb 23;31(3):184. doi: 10.1007/s00520-023-07625-6.
To improve shared decision making (SDM) with advanced cancer patients, communication skills training for oncologists is needed. The purpose was to examine the effects of a blended online learning (i.e. e-learning and online training session) for oncologists about SDM in palliative oncological care and to compare this blended format with a more extensive, fully in-person face-to-face training format.
A one-group pre-posttest design was adopted. Before (T0) and after (T2) training, participants conducted simulated consultations (SPAs) and surveys; after the e-learning (T1), an additional survey was filled out. The primary outcome was observed SDM (OPTION12 and 4SDM). Secondary outcomes included observed SDM per stage, SPA duration and decision made as well as oncologists' self-reported knowledge, clinical behavioural intentions, satisfaction with the communication and evaluation of the training. Additionally, outcomes of the blended learning were compared with those of the face-to-face training cohort. Analyses were conducted in SPSS by linear mixed models.
Oncologists (n = 17) showed significantly higher SDM scores after the blended online learning. The individual stages of SDM and the number of times the decision was postponed as well as oncologists' beliefs about capabilities, knowledge and satisfaction increased after the blended learning. Consultation duration was unchanged. The training was evaluated as satisfactory. When compared with the face-to-face training, the blended learning effects were smaller.
Blended online SDM training for oncologists was effective. However, the effects were smaller compared to face-to-face training. The availability of different training formats provides opportunities for tailoring training to the wishes and needs of learners.
为了改善晚期癌症患者的共同决策(SDM),需要对肿瘤医生进行沟通技巧培训。本研究旨在考察一种混合式在线学习(即电子学习和在线培训课程)对姑息肿瘤学中 SDM 的肿瘤医生的效果,并将这种混合式学习与更广泛的、完全面对面的培训形式进行比较。
采用单组前后测试设计。在培训前(T0)和培训后(T2),参与者进行了模拟咨询(SPAs)和调查;在电子学习后(T1),还填写了额外的调查。主要结局指标是观察到的 SDM(OPTION12 和 4SDM)。次要结局指标包括每个阶段的观察 SDM、SPA 持续时间和决策,以及肿瘤医生的自我报告知识、临床行为意向、对沟通的满意度和对培训的评价。此外,还比较了混合学习的结果与面对面培训组的结果。分析采用 SPSS 线性混合模型进行。
肿瘤医生(n=17)在接受混合式在线学习后,SDM 评分显著提高。SDM 的各个阶段、决策被推迟的次数以及肿瘤医生对能力、知识和满意度的信念在混合学习后增加。咨询持续时间保持不变。培训被评估为令人满意。与面对面培训相比,混合学习的效果较小。
混合式在线 SDM 培训对肿瘤医生有效。然而,与面对面培训相比,效果较小。提供不同的培训形式为根据学习者的意愿和需求定制培训提供了机会。