Glass S, Gray M, Eden O B, Hann I
Department of Haematology, Royal Hospital for Sick Children, Edinburgh, Scotland.
Leuk Res. 1987;11(10):881-5. doi: 10.1016/0145-2126(87)90133-0.
This study attempted to validate central registration data on all childhood leukaemia cases in Scotland between 1968 and 1981 in line with the Black Enquiry concerning West Cumbria. Missing files precluded a complete verification, but minor errors of registration were found in 44% of cases. A small number of important mistakes of omission (eight cases), wrong diagnosis (six cases) and postal code errors (nine cases) were found which might affect epidemiological studies of these relatively rare diseases. Precise and verified prospective data collection at the time of diagnosis is essential if the spatial distribution of childhood cancers is being studied.
本研究试图依照关于西坎布里亚郡的布莱克调查,对1968年至1981年间苏格兰所有儿童白血病病例的中央登记数据进行验证。缺失的档案妨碍了全面核查,但在44%的病例中发现了登记方面的小错误。还发现了少量重要的遗漏错误(8例)、错误诊断(6例)和邮政编码错误(9例),这些可能会影响对这些相对罕见疾病的流行病学研究。如果要研究儿童癌症的空间分布,在诊断时进行精确且经过验证的前瞻性数据收集至关重要。