Albano Giuseppe Davide, Guadagnino Daniela, Midiri Mauro, La Spina Corinne, Tullio Valeria, Argo Antonina, Zerbo Stefania
Section of Legal Medicine, Department of Health Promotion, Mother and Child Care, Internal Medicine and Medical Specialties, University of Palermo, 90129 Palermo, Italy.
Interdepartmental Center of Research (CIR) "Migrare" on Migration, University of Palermo, 90129 Palermo, Italy.
Healthcare (Basel). 2023 Feb 15;11(4):576. doi: 10.3390/healthcare11040576.
The maltreatment and torture of prisoners constitute a global problem. Methods of maltreatment are classified as the psychological and the physical, and physical methods inevitably lead to psychological sequelae. Our review offers an analysis from the medico-legal perspective of the literature on the torture and physical and sexual abuse experienced by prisoners and their psychological sequelae and aims to investigate the medico-legal issues of investigating maltreatment in prison so as to suggest methodologies and updated approaches for dealing with such cases in a forensic context. We performed a comprehensive literature search of peer-reviewed publications (articles and reviews), research reports, case studies, books, service models, protocols, and institutional documents available online using key electronic databases (Scopus, PubMed) and search engines (Google Scholar) with the following keywords: physical violence, psychological violence, torture, maltreatment, physical abuse, psychological abuse AND prison OR prisoner OR jail OR custody. In the medical literature, most of the publications on torture are based on retrospective studies of torture among survivors and often refer to asylum seekers. Forensic evaluation is crucial for assessing the determinant elements of torture and maltreatment. A multidisciplinary approach and standardized and updated methodologies are needed to support policymakers, national institutions, and public health system initiatives in this field.
对囚犯的虐待和酷刑是一个全球性问题。虐待方法分为心理虐待和身体虐待,而身体虐待不可避免地会导致心理后遗症。我们的综述从法医学角度对有关囚犯遭受的酷刑、身体和性虐待及其心理后遗症的文献进行了分析,旨在调查监狱中虐待调查的法医学问题,从而提出在法医背景下处理此类案件的方法和更新途径。我们使用关键电子数据库(Scopus、PubMed)和搜索引擎(谷歌学术),通过以下关键词对同行评审出版物(文章和综述)、研究报告、案例研究、书籍、服务模式、协议和在线可得的机构文件进行了全面的文献检索:身体暴力、心理暴力、酷刑、虐待、身体虐待、心理虐待以及监狱、囚犯、看守所、羁押。在医学文献中,大多数关于酷刑的出版物基于对幸存者酷刑经历的回顾性研究,且常常涉及寻求庇护者。法医评估对于评估酷刑和虐待的决定性因素至关重要。需要一种多学科方法以及标准化和更新的方法,以支持该领域的政策制定者、国家机构和公共卫生系统倡议。