Department of Gender and Women's Studies, University of Wisconsin-Madison, Madison, WI, 53706, USA.
Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, University of Wisconsin-Madison, Madison, WI, 53706, USA.
Stud Fam Plann. 2023 Mar;54(1):231-250. doi: 10.1111/sifp.12233. Epub 2023 Feb 26.
Unmet need for contraception is a widely used but frequently misunderstood indicator. Although calculated from measures of pregnancy intention and current contraceptive use, unmet need is commonly used as a proxy measure for (1) lack of access to contraception and (2) desire to use it. Using data from a survey in Burkina Faso, we examine the extent to which unmet need corresponds with and diverges from these two concepts, calculating sensitivity, specificity, and positive/negative predictive values. Among women assigned conventional unmet need, 67 percent report no desire to use contraception and 61 percent report access to a broad range of affordable contraceptives. Results show unmet need has low sensitivity and specificity in differentiating those who lack access and/or who desire to use a method from those who do not. These findings suggest that unmet need is of limited utility to inform family planning programs and may be leading stakeholders to overestimate the proportion of women in need of expanded family planning services. We conclude that more direct measures are feasible at the population level, rendering the proxy measure of unmet need unnecessary. Where access to and/or desire for contraception are the true outcomes of interest, more direct measures should be used.
避孕需求未得到满足是一个广泛使用但经常被误解的指标。虽然它是根据怀孕意愿和当前避孕方法使用情况计算得出的,但避孕需求未得到满足通常被用作(1)缺乏避孕措施和(2)希望使用避孕措施的替代指标。我们使用布基纳法索调查的数据,研究了避孕需求未得到满足在多大程度上与这两个概念相吻合和相背离,计算了敏感性、特异性和阳性/阴性预测值。在被分配常规避孕需求未得到满足的妇女中,67%的人表示没有使用避孕措施的愿望,61%的人表示可以获得广泛的负担得起的避孕方法。结果表明,在区分那些缺乏获得避孕措施和/或希望使用避孕方法的人和那些不希望使用避孕方法的人方面,避孕需求未得到满足的敏感性和特异性都较低。这些发现表明,避孕需求未得到满足在为计划生育方案提供信息方面的作用有限,可能导致利益相关者高估需要扩大计划生育服务的妇女比例。我们的结论是,在人口层面上更直接的措施是可行的,因此不需要使用代理指标。如果关注的是获得和/或对避孕措施的需求,那么应该使用更直接的措施。