Mackie Louise, Huber Ludwig
Comparative Cognition, Messerli Research Institute, University of Veterinary Medicine Vienna, Vienna, Austria.
Front Psychol. 2023 Feb 17;14:1063132. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2023.1063132. eCollection 2023.
Overimitation - the copying of another's unnecessary or irrelevant actions toward a goal - is largely considered to be uniquely human. Recent studies, however, have found evidence of this behavior in dogs. Humans seem to overimitate more or less depending on social factors, such as the cultural origin of the demonstrator. Like humans, dogs may have social motivations behind their overimitation, since they have been shown to copy irrelevant actions more from their caregivers than from strangers. By using priming methodology, this study aimed to investigate whether dogs' overimitation can be facilitated the experimental manipulation of their attachment-based motivations. To test this, we invited caregivers to demonstrate goal-irrelevant and relevant actions to their dog, following either a dog-caregiver relationship prime, a dog-caregiver attention prime, or no prime. Our results showed no significant main effect of priming on copying behavior for either relevant or irrelevant actions, but we found a trend that unprimed dogs copied the least actions overall. Additionally, dogs copied their caregiver's relevant actions more often and more faithfully as the number of trials increased. Our final finding was that dogs were much more likely to copy irrelevant actions after (rather than before) already achieving the goal. This study discusses the social motivations behind dog imitative behavior, and has potential methodological implications regarding the influence of priming on dog behavioral studies.
过度模仿——对实现某个目标时他人不必要或不相关动作的模仿——在很大程度上被认为是人类独有的行为。然而,最近的研究发现了狗身上存在这种行为的证据。人类的过度模仿似乎或多或少取决于社会因素,比如示范者的文化背景。和人类一样,狗的过度模仿背后可能也有社会动机,因为研究表明,比起陌生人,狗从它们的照料者那里更倾向于模仿不相关的动作。本研究采用启动方法,旨在探究狗的过度模仿是否能通过对其基于依恋的动机进行实验操控来促进。为了验证这一点,我们邀请照料者向他们的狗展示与目标无关和相关的动作,分别在狗-照料者关系启动、狗-照料者注意力启动或无启动的情况下进行。我们的结果显示,启动对相关或不相关动作的模仿行为均无显著的主效应,但我们发现一个趋势,即未启动的狗总体上模仿的动作最少。此外,随着试验次数的增加,狗更频繁、更忠实地模仿照料者的相关动作。我们的最终发现是,狗在已经实现目标之后(而非之前)更有可能模仿不相关的动作。本研究讨论了狗模仿行为背后的社会动机,并对启动对狗行为研究的影响具有潜在的方法学意义。