Alavi-Naini Roya, Sargolzaie Narjes, Metanat Maliheh
Infectious Diseases and Tropical Medicine Research Center, Resistant Tuberculosis Institute, Zahedan University of Medical Sciences, Zahedan, Iran.
Clinical Immunology Research Center, Zahedan University of Medical Sciences, Zahedan, Iran.
Tanaffos. 2022 Feb;21(2):154-160.
Ecological studies showed that countries with national Bacillus Calmette-Guerin (BCG) vaccination programs for tuberculosis prevention reported lower incidences of severe and fatal COVID-19 than countries without such programs. Several studies have demonstrated that the BCG vaccine can induce long-term trained Immunity in bone marrow progenitor cells. In this study, we tried to evaluate the relationship between tuberculin skin test results, BCG scar, and COVID-19 outcomes among patients with confirmed COVID-19.
This was a cross-sectional study. Cases included 160 patients with confirmed COVID-19 in Zahedan hospitals (southeast Iran) in 2020, selected by convenient sampling. PPD test was performed for all patients through the intradermal technique. Collected data included demographic information, underlying conditions, PPD test results, and COVID-19 outcome. Analysis was conducted utilizing ANOVA, χ2 test, and multivariate analysis (logistic regression).
The univariate analysis showed a positive relationship between older age, having underlying diseases, and positive tuberculin skin test results with the outcome of COVID-19. We also found a lower frequency of BCG scar among patients with death outcomes than recovered ones. In the multivariate analysis by logistic regression through the backward method, only age and underlying diseases remained predictors of death.
Tuberculin test results might be dependent on age and underlying conditions. Our study did not show relationship between BCG vaccine and mortality in COVID-19 patients. Further investigations in different settings are required to reveal the efficacy of the BCG vaccine in preventing this devastating disease.
生态学研究表明,实施国家卡介苗(BCG)接种计划以预防结核病的国家报告的严重和致命性 COVID-19 发病率低于未实施此类计划的国家。多项研究表明,卡介苗可在骨髓祖细胞中诱导长期的训练免疫。在本研究中,我们试图评估确诊 COVID-19 患者的结核菌素皮肤试验结果、卡介苗疤痕与 COVID-19 结局之间的关系。
这是一项横断面研究。病例包括 2020 年在伊朗东南部扎黑丹医院确诊的 160 例 COVID-19 患者,采用方便抽样法选取。通过皮内技术对所有患者进行结核菌素试验。收集的数据包括人口统计学信息、基础疾病、结核菌素试验结果和 COVID-19 结局。采用方差分析、χ2 检验和多变量分析(逻辑回归)进行分析。
单变量分析显示,年龄较大、患有基础疾病以及结核菌素皮肤试验结果呈阳性与 COVID-19 结局呈正相关。我们还发现,死亡患者的卡介苗疤痕发生率低于康复患者。在通过向后法进行的逻辑回归多变量分析中,只有年龄和基础疾病仍然是死亡的预测因素。
结核菌素试验结果可能取决于年龄和基础疾病。我们的研究未显示卡介苗与 COVID-19 患者死亡率之间的关系。需要在不同环境中进行进一步研究,以揭示卡介苗在预防这种毁灭性疾病方面的疗效。