All India Institute of Medical Sciences, Jodhpur, India.
Vardhman Mahavir Medical College and Safdarjung Hospital, New Delhi, India.
BMC Pregnancy Childbirth. 2023 Mar 10;23(1):159. doi: 10.1186/s12884-022-05327-1.
Despite an increase in institutional births and a fall in maternal mortality, the satisfaction of women with their birthing experience in public health institutions is low. Birth Companion (BC) is an important part of the Labour Room Quality Improvement Initiative introduced by the Government of India in 2017. Despite mandates, its implementation has been unsatisfactory. Little is known about the perception of healthcare providers about BC.
We conducted a facility-based, cross-sectional quantitative study with doctors and nurses in a tertiary care hospital in Delhi, India to gauge their awareness, perception and knowledge about BC. Following universal total population sampling, the participants were administered a questionnaire, which was completed by 96 of 115 serving doctors (response rate of 83%), and 55 of 105 serving nurses (response rate of 52%).
Most (93%) healthcare providers were aware of the concept of BC, WHO's recommendation (83%) and Government's instructions (68%) on BC during labour. A woman's mother was the BC of choice (70%) closely followed by her husband (69%). Ninety-five percent of providers agreed that the presence of a BC during labour will be beneficial, in providing emotional support, boosting the woman's confidence, providing comfort measures, helping in the early initiation of breastfeeding, reducing post-partum depression, humanizing labour, reducing the need for analgesia and increasing chances of spontaneous vaginal births. Yet, support for the introduction of BC in their hospital was low due to institutional barriers like overcrowding, lack of privacy, hospital policy, risk of infection; privacy issues and costs.
Widespread adoption of the concept of BC would require, besides directives, a buy-in by the providers, and action on their suggestions. These include greater funding for hospitals, creating physical partitions to ensure privacy, sensitization and training of health providers and BC, incentivizing hospitals and birthing women, formulation of guidelines on BC, standards setting and a change in institutional culture.
尽管机构分娩率有所增加,产妇死亡率有所下降,但女性对其在公立医疗机构分娩体验的满意度仍然较低。分娩陪伴员(Birth Companion,BC)是印度政府于 2017 年推出的《产房质量改进倡议》的重要组成部分。尽管有相关规定,但执行情况并不令人满意。对于医疗保健提供者对 BC 的看法知之甚少。
我们在印度德里的一家三级保健医院进行了一项基于机构的横断面定量研究,以了解医生和护士对 BC 的认识、看法和知识。在对全体服务人群进行普查后,为参与者发放了一份问卷,115 名服务医生中有 96 名(回应率为 83%),105 名服务护士中有 55 名(回应率为 52%)完成了问卷。
大多数(93%)医疗保健提供者都了解 BC 的概念、世卫组织的推荐(83%)和政府关于分娩时 BC 的指示(68%)。在分娩时,女性的母亲(70%)是首选的 BC,其次是她的丈夫(69%)。95%的提供者都同意,在分娩时提供 BC 将是有益的,可以提供情感支持、增强女性信心、提供舒适措施、帮助尽早开始母乳喂养、减少产后抑郁、人性化分娩、减少对镇痛的需求以及增加自然分娩的机会。然而,由于医院过度拥挤、缺乏隐私、医院政策、感染风险、隐私问题和费用等机构障碍,他们对在自己的医院引入 BC 的支持率较低。
要广泛采用 BC 这一概念,除了指令之外,还需要提供者的认同,并对他们的建议采取行动。这些建议包括为医院提供更多资金,创建物理隔板以确保隐私,对卫生保健提供者和 BC 进行宣传和培训,对医院和分娩妇女进行激励,制定 BC 指南、设定标准以及改变机构文化。