State Key Laboratory of Cognitive Neuroscience and Learning, IDG/McGovern Institute for Brain Research, Beijing Normal University, Beijing, China.
School of Psychology, Capital Normal University, Beijing, China.
Psychiatry Clin Neurosci. 2023 Jul;77(7):386-392. doi: 10.1111/pcn.13543. Epub 2023 Mar 30.
Patients with Turner syndrome have a high rate of developmental dyscalculia, but the underlying neurocognitive mechanisms are not well-understood. Some studies have implicated visuospatial impairments in patients with Turner syndrome, but others have focused on poor procedural skills in patients with Turner syndrome. This study used brain imaging data to test these two alternative views.
This study recruited 44 girls with Turner syndrome (mean age, 12.91 years; SD, 2.02), with 13 (29.5%) of them meeting the criterion for developmental dyscalculia, and 14 normally developing girls (mean age, 14.26 years; SD, 2.18) as a comparison group. All participants were given basic mathematical ability tests and an intelligence test and were scanned using magnetic resonance imaging. We compared patients with Turner syndrome who had dyscalculia, patients with Turner syndrome who did not have dyscalculia, and the normal controls in terms of brain structures and resting-state functional activity.
Compared with normal controls, both groups of patients with Turner syndrome (with or without dyscalculia) showed similarly altered functional connectivity in the occipitoparietal dorsal stream. Importantly, compared with patients with Turner syndrome without dyscalculia and normal controls, patients with Turner syndrome with dyscalculia showed decreased functional connectivity between the prefrontal and the lateral occipital cortex.
We concluded that both groups of patients with Turner syndrome shared visual deficits, and patients with Turner syndrome with dyscalculia had a deficit in frontal cortex-based higher cognitive processing. It is not their visuospatial deficits but rather their deficits in higher cognitive processing that are responsible for the development of dyscalculia in patients with Turner syndrome.
特纳综合征患者的发育性计算障碍发生率很高,但神经认知机制尚不清楚。一些研究表明特纳综合征患者存在视觉空间障碍,但其他研究则侧重于特纳综合征患者的程序性技能较差。本研究使用脑成像数据来检验这两种替代观点。
本研究招募了 44 名特纳综合征女孩(平均年龄 12.91 岁,标准差 2.02),其中 13 名(29.5%)符合发育性计算障碍标准,14 名正常发育女孩(平均年龄 14.26 岁,标准差 2.18)作为对照组。所有参与者均接受了基础数学能力测试和智力测试,并接受了磁共振成像扫描。我们比较了患有计算障碍的特纳综合征患者、没有计算障碍的特纳综合征患者和正常对照组的大脑结构和静息状态功能活动。
与正常对照组相比,两组特纳综合征患者(有或没有计算障碍)的顶枕部背侧流的功能连接均发生了类似的改变。重要的是,与没有计算障碍的特纳综合征患者和正常对照组相比,患有计算障碍的特纳综合征患者的前额叶和外侧枕叶之间的功能连接减少。
我们得出结论,两组特纳综合征患者均存在视觉缺陷,而患有计算障碍的特纳综合征患者则存在基于额叶的高级认知处理缺陷。导致特纳综合征患者出现计算障碍的原因不是他们的视觉空间缺陷,而是他们的高级认知处理缺陷。