McGill University, 845 Sherbrooke West, Montreal, Quebec H3A 0G4, Canada.
J Sch Psychol. 2023 Apr;97:43-62. doi: 10.1016/j.jsp.2022.10.007. Epub 2023 Jan 25.
Mindfulness-based programs (MBPs) are increasingly used in educational institutions to enhance students' mental health and resilience. However, reviews of the literature suggest this use may have outpaced the evidence base and further research is needed to better understand the mechanisms underlying these programs' effectiveness and which outcomes are being affected. The purpose of this meta-analysis was to investigate the strength of MBPs' effects on school adjustment and mindfulness outcomes while also considering the potential influence of study and program characteristics, including the role of comparison groups, students' educational level, the type of program being used, and the facilitator's training and previous mindfulness experience. Following a systematic review of five databases, 46 studies using a randomized controlled design with students from preschool to undergraduate levels were selected. At post-program, the effect of MBPs compared to control groups was (a) small for overall school adjustment outcomes, academic performance, and impulsivity; (b) small to moderate for attention; and (c) moderate for mindfulness. No differences emerged for interpersonal skills, school functioning, or student behaviour. The effects of MBPs on overall school adjustment and mindfulness differed based on students' educational level and the type of program being delivered. Moreover, only MBPs delivered by outside facilitators with previous experience of mindfulness had significant effects on either school adjustment or mindfulness. This meta-analysis provides promising evidence of the effectiveness of MBPs in educational contexts to improve students' school adjustment outcomes beyond typically assessed psychological benefits, even when using randomized controlled designs.
正念为基础的项目(MBPs)在教育机构中越来越多地被用于提高学生的心理健康和适应力。然而,文献综述表明,这种使用可能已经超过了证据基础,需要进一步研究以更好地理解这些项目有效性的背后机制,以及哪些结果受到了影响。本荟萃分析的目的是调查 MBPs 对学校适应和正念结果的影响强度,同时考虑研究和项目特征的潜在影响,包括对照组的作用、学生的教育水平、所使用的项目类型以及促进者的培训和之前的正念经验。在对五个数据库进行系统综述后,选择了 46 项使用随机对照设计的研究,研究对象为从学龄前到本科阶段的学生。在项目后,MBPs 与对照组相比,在总体学校适应结果、学业成绩和冲动性方面的效果为(a)小;在注意力方面的效果为(b)小到中;在正念方面的效果为(c)中。在人际关系技能、学校功能或学生行为方面没有差异。MBPs 对总体学校适应和正念的影响取决于学生的教育水平和所提供的项目类型。此外,只有由具有正念经验的外部促进者提供的 MBPs 对学校适应或正念有显著影响。本荟萃分析为 MBPs 在教育环境中改善学生的学校适应结果提供了有希望的证据,这些结果超出了通常评估的心理益处,即使使用随机对照设计也是如此。