Department of Physics, University of Maryland, College Park, MD 20742.
Institute for Research in Electronics and Applied Physics, University of Maryland, College Park, MD 20742.
Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2023 Mar 21;120(12):e2216030120. doi: 10.1073/pnas.2216030120. Epub 2023 Mar 16.
Network link inference from measured time series data of the behavior of dynamically interacting network nodes is an important problem with wide-ranging applications, e.g., estimating synaptic connectivity among neurons from measurements of their calcium fluorescence. Network inference methods typically begin by using the measured time series to assign to any given ordered pair of nodes a numerical score reflecting the likelihood of a directed link between those two nodes. In typical cases, the measured time series data may be subject to limitations, including limited duration, low sampling rate, observational noise, and partial nodal state measurement. However, it is unknown how the performance of link inference techniques on such datasets depends on these experimental limitations of data acquisition. Here, we utilize both synthetic data generated from coupled chaotic systems as well as experimental data obtained from neural activity to systematically assess the influence of data limitations on the character of scores reflecting the likelihood of a directed link between a given node pair. We do this for three network inference techniques: Granger causality, transfer entropy, and, a machine learning-based method. Furthermore, we assess the ability of appropriate surrogate data to determine statistical confidence levels associated with the results of link-inference techniques.
从动态相互作用的网络节点的行为的测量时间序列数据中推断网络连接是一个具有广泛应用的重要问题,例如,从神经元的钙荧光测量中估计神经元之间的突触连接。网络推断方法通常首先使用测量的时间序列为任何给定的有序节点对分配一个数值分数,反映这两个节点之间有向连接的可能性。在典型情况下,测量的时间序列数据可能受到限制,包括有限的持续时间、低采样率、观测噪声和部分节点状态测量。然而,目前还不清楚在这些数据集上链接推断技术的性能如何取决于数据采集的这些实验限制。在这里,我们利用从耦合混沌系统生成的合成数据以及从神经活动中获得的实验数据,系统地评估数据限制对反映给定节点对之间有向连接可能性的分数特征的影响。我们为三种网络推断技术进行了评估:格兰杰因果关系、传递熵和基于机器学习的方法。此外,我们评估了适当的替代数据确定与链接推断技术结果相关的统计置信水平的能力。