Heinrich Ewald Hering's discovery of the heart pacemaker: Hering, Tawara and Aschoff's search for its morphological basis, the sinoatrial node, and why they failed.

Two groups of investigators investigated the heart pacemaker and its morphological basis in the early twentieth century. The first group was formed by Henrich Ewald Hering (physiologist), Sunao Tawara and Ludwig Aschoff (morphologists). The second group was composed of James Mackenzie (general practitioner and clinical investigator), Arthur Keith and Martin Flack (morphologists). These groups were formed almost at the same time in 1903. Their work resulted in the discovery of the atrioventricular node and Purkinje network (Sunao Tawara, in 1906), heart pacemaker (H E Hering, in 1907) and sinoatrial node (Keith and Flack, in 1907). Here, it is shown how the interconnections of the concurrent works of these groups resulted in the discovery not only of the function, but also of the structure of the sinoatrial node.