School of Population Health, Curtin University, Bentley, Western Australia, Australia.
PLoS One. 2023 Mar 23;18(3):e0279750. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0279750. eCollection 2023.
Online shaming, where people engage in social policing by shaming perceived transgressions via the internet, is a widespread global phenomenon. Despite its negative consequences, scarce research has been conducted and existing knowledge is largely anecdotal. Using a correlational online survey, this mixed-method study firstly assessed whether moral grandstanding, moral disengagement, emotional reactivity, empathy, social vigilantism, online disinhibition, machiavellianism, narcissism, and psychopathy predict participants' (N = 411; aged 15-78) likelihood to engage in online shaming. Two hierarchical multiple regression analyses revealed these predictors significantly accounted for 39% of variance in online shaming intentions, and 20% of variance in perceived deservedness of online shaming (f2 = .25 and .64 respectively, p < .001). A content analysis of an open-ended question offered further insights into public opinions about online shaming. These qualitative findings included the perception of online shaming as a form of accountability, the perceived destructive effects of online shaming, the perceived role of anonymity in online shaming, online shaming as a form of entertainment, online shaming involving 'two sides to every story', the notion that 'hurt people hurt people', online shaming as now a social norm, and the distinction between the online shaming of public and private figures. These findings can be used to inform the general public and advise appropriate responses from service providers and policy makers to mitigate damaging impacts of this phenomenon.
网络羞辱是一种普遍的全球现象,人们通过互联网羞辱被认为是违规的行为,从而进行社会监督。尽管网络羞辱带来了负面影响,但相关研究却很少,现有的知识也主要是传闻。本混合方法研究使用相关的在线调查,首先评估了道德虚饰、道德脱离、情绪反应性、同理心、社会警戒、线上去抑制、马基雅维利主义、自恋和精神病态是否预测参与者(N=411;年龄 15-78 岁)参与网络羞辱的可能性。两项分层多元回归分析表明,这些预测因素显著解释了 39%的网络羞辱意图和 20%的网络羞辱应得感的方差(f2分别为.25 和.64,p<.001)。对一个开放式问题的内容分析提供了关于公众对网络羞辱看法的进一步见解。这些定性发现包括将网络羞辱视为一种问责形式、对网络羞辱的破坏性影响的认识、匿名在网络羞辱中的作用、网络羞辱作为一种娱乐形式、网络羞辱涉及“每一个故事都有两面”、“伤害人的人也会被人伤害”的观念、网络羞辱已成为一种社会规范,以及公众人物和私人人物的网络羞辱之间的区别。这些发现可用于告知公众,并为服务提供商和政策制定者提供适当的应对措施,以减轻这种现象的破坏性影响。