Metzger Gregory A, Minneci Peter M, Gehred Alison, Day Alexis, Klingele Kevin E
Center for Surgical Outcomes Research, Abigail Wexner Research Institute, Nationwide Children's Hospital, Columbus, OH, USA.
Nationwide Children's Hospital Library, Columbus, OH, USA.
J Orthop. 2023 Mar 25;38:73-78. doi: 10.1016/j.jor.2023.03.010. eCollection 2023 Apr.
An increase in intra-muscular creatine through supplementation has been proposed as a strategy for improving muscle performance and recovery, with studies showing some benefit for adult athletes who rely on short, explosive movements. We reviewed and summarized the current literature on creatine supplementation in a pediatric and adolescent population.
The databases PubMed and EMBASE were queried to identity articles related to the use of creatine supplementation in a healthy pediatric and adolescent population according to the guidelines established by PRISMA. The abstracts of all articles were reviewed to determine relevancy, with those meeting the pre-defined criteria included in the final review.
A combined total of 9393 articles were identified. Following application of filters and review of abstracts, 13 articles were found to meet criteria and were included in the final review. There was a total of 268 subjects across all studies, with mean age ranging from 11.5 to 18.2 years. More than 75% of the studies were randomized-controlled trials, and 85% involved either soccer players or swimmers. The overall quality of the studies was poor, and there were no consistent findings regarding creatine supplementation and improvements in athletic performance. No studies were designed to address the topic of safety.
There is a gap in the study of the safety and efficacy of creatine supplementation in adolescents. Additional studies are needed to evaluate the effects of alterations in muscle composition on the growth, development, and performance of the developing athlete. Orthopedic providers should counsel their pediatric and adolescent patients on the current limitations in trying to assess the true risk and benefit of creatine supplementation for the aspiring athlete.
Review, III.
有人提出通过补充肌内肌酸作为改善肌肉性能和恢复的一种策略,研究表明这对依赖短时间爆发性运动的成年运动员有一定益处。我们回顾并总结了当前关于儿科和青少年人群补充肌酸的文献。
根据PRISMA制定的指南,查询PubMed和EMBASE数据库,以确定与健康儿科和青少年人群使用肌酸补充剂相关的文章。对所有文章的摘要进行审查以确定相关性,符合预定义标准的文章纳入最终审查。
共识别出9393篇文章。应用筛选器并审查摘要后,发现13篇文章符合标准并纳入最终审查。所有研究共有268名受试者,平均年龄在11.5至18.2岁之间。超过75%的研究为随机对照试验,85%涉及足球运动员或游泳运动员。研究的总体质量较差,关于补充肌酸与运动成绩改善方面没有一致的发现。没有研究旨在解决安全性问题。
青少年补充肌酸的安全性和有效性研究存在空白。需要更多研究来评估肌肉成分改变对发育中运动员的生长、发育和表现的影响。骨科医生应就目前在评估有抱负的运动员补充肌酸的真正风险和益处方面的局限性,向他们的儿科和青少年患者提供咨询。
综述,III级