Royal Free London NHS Foundation Trust, London, United Kingdom.
Wirral University Teaching Hospital NHS Foundation Trust, Wirral, United Kingdom.
Int J Surg. 2023 May 1;109(5):1136-1140. doi: 10.1097/JS9.0000000000000373.
The Surgical CAse REport (SCARE) guidelines were first published in 2016 as a tool for surgeons to document and report their surgical cases in a standardised and comprehensive manner. However, with advances in technology and changes in the healthcare landscape, it is important to revise and update these guidelines to ensure they remain relevant and valuable for surgeons.
The updated guidelines were produced through a Delphi consensus exercise. Members of the SCARE 2020 guidelines Delphi group, editorial board members, and peer reviewers were invited to participate. Potential contributors were contacted by e-mail. An online survey was completed to indicate their agreement with the proposed changes to the guideline items.
A total of 54 participants were invited to participate and 44 (81.5%) completed the survey. There was a high degree of agreement among reviewers, with 36 items (83.7%) meeting the threshold for inclusion.
Through a completed Delphi consensus exercise we present the SCARE 2023 guidelines. This will provide surgeons with a comprehensive and up-to-date tool for documenting and reporting their surgical cases while highlighting the importance of patient-centred care.
外科病例报告(SCARE)指南于 2016 年首次发布,旨在为外科医生提供一种标准化和全面的方法来记录和报告他们的手术病例。然而,随着技术的进步和医疗保健领域的变化,修订和更新这些指南以确保它们仍然对外科医生具有相关性和价值非常重要。
更新的指南是通过 Delphi 共识实践产生的。邀请了 SCARE 2020 指南 Delphi 小组的成员、编辑委员会成员和同行评审员参与。通过电子邮件联系潜在的贡献者。完成了在线调查,以表明他们对指南项目的拟议更改的同意程度。
共有 54 名参与者受邀参加,其中 44 名(81.5%)完成了调查。评审员之间存在高度的一致性,其中 36 个项目(83.7%)达到了纳入标准。
通过完成 Delphi 共识实践,我们提出了 SCARE 2023 指南。这将为外科医生提供一个全面和最新的工具,用于记录和报告他们的手术病例,同时强调以患者为中心的护理的重要性。