Anceschi Umberto, Morelli Michele, Flammia Rocco Simone, Brassetti Aldo, Dell'Oglio Paolo, Galfano Antonio, Tappero Stefano, Vecchio Enrico, Martiriggiano Marco, Luciani Lorenzo Giuseppe, Sperduti Isabella, Albisinni Simone, Tuderti Gabriele, Prata Francesco, Ferriero Maria Consiglia, Bove Alfredo Maria, Mastroianni Riccardo, Spadaro Giuseppe, Russo Andrea, Mattevi Daniele, Tufano Antonio, Leonardo Costantino, Lombardo Riccardo, De Nunzio Cosimo, Cai Tommaso, Quackels Thierry, Bocciardi Aldo Massimo, Simone Giuseppe
IRCCS 'Regina Elena' National Cancer Institute, Department of Urology, Rome, Italy.
Ospedale Niguarda Ca' Granda, Department of Urology, Milan, Italy.
Cent European J Urol. 2023;76(1):38-43. doi: 10.5173/ceju.2023.260. Epub 2023 Mar 3.
The aim of this series was to evaluate predictors of Proficiency score (PS) achievement on a multicentric series of robot-assisted radical prostatectomies (RARP) performed by trainee surgeons with two different surgical techniques at four tertiary-care centers.
Four institutional datasets were merged and queried for RARPs performed by surgeons during their learning curve (LC) between 2010 and 2020 using two different approaches (Group A, Retzius-sparing RARP, n = 164; Group B, standard anterograde RARP, n = 79). Logistic regression analysis was performed to identify predictors of PS achievement for the overall trainee cohort. For all analyses, a two-sided p <0.05 was considered significant.
Group B showed significantly increased median operative time, positive surgical margins (PSM) status, increased number of nerve-sparing procedures, shorter LC time (each p <0.04). PS, continence status, potency, biochemical recurrence and 1-year trifecta rates were comparable between groups (each p >0.3). On multivariable analysis, time from LC starting ≥12 months (OR = 2.79; 95%IC [1.15-6.76]; p = 0.02) and a nerve-sparing intent (OR = 3.18; 95%IC [1.15-8.77]; p = 0.02) were independent predictors of PS score achievement (Table 3).
Higher PS rates for RARP trainees may be expected after 12 months from LC beginning. Short-term training courses are unlikely to confer proper surgical training, while long-term structured training programs seem to be beneficial on perioperative outcomes.
本系列研究的目的是评估在四个三级医疗中心,由实习外科医生采用两种不同手术技术进行的多中心机器人辅助根治性前列腺切除术(RARP)中,达到熟练程度评分(PS)的预测因素。
合并了四个机构的数据集,并查询了2010年至2020年期间外科医生在学习曲线(LC)阶段使用两种不同方法进行的RARP手术(A组,保留Retzius间隙的RARP,n = 164;B组,标准顺行RARP,n = 79)。进行逻辑回归分析以确定整个实习医生队列中达到PS的预测因素。对于所有分析,双侧p <0.05被认为具有统计学意义。
B组的中位手术时间显著延长,手术切缘阳性(PSM)状态增加,保留神经手术的数量增加,LC时间缩短(各p <0.04)。两组之间的PS、控尿状态、性功能、生化复发和1年三联成功(切缘阴性、控尿和性功能保留)率相当(各p >0.3)。多变量分析显示,从LC开始起时间≥12个月(OR = 2.79;95%置信区间[1.15 - �.76];p = 0.02)和保留神经的意图(OR = 3.18;95%置信区间[1.15 - 8.77];p = 0.02)是PS评分达标的独立预测因素(表3)。
预计RARP实习医生从LC开始12个月后PS率会更高。短期培训课程不太可能提供适当的手术培训,而长期结构化培训计划似乎对围手术期结果有益。