Department of Nursing, State University of Applied Sciences in Piła, Piła, Poland.
BMC Med Educ. 2023 Apr 17;23(1):255. doi: 10.1186/s12909-023-04223-2.
Comics, as an art form that combines words and images, can be used with great success in teaching nursing students. Teaching content on multicultural issues is not easy, especially since, in addition to knowledge, it is important to pay attention to communication skills, attitudes of respect, openness or empathy, among others. It is difficult to recognize or discuss these attitudes without student involvement. Graphic stories, comic strips provide such opportunities and facilitate learning new content, even those difficult to communicate naturally and spontaneously. The aim of this paper is to present the possibilities of using the graphic method, in particular comics and graphic novels, in teaching nursing, based on the example of multicultural nursing.
Quasi-experimental intervention study with a quantitative approach, guided by the STROBE tool The survey was conducted March-May 2022 among State University of Applied Sciences in Piła students. First, students' knowledge of cultural issues was assessed, then they were randomly assigned to two groups. One group had classes using a comic book, and the other group had classes using traditional methods. After the class, the students' knowledge was assessed again. Descriptive statistical analyses were performed to obtain the mean, median, standard deviation (SD). Data followed a normal distribution. Data was verified by the t-Students test for independent groups.
Respondents' knowledge on cultural issues before taking the course was satisfactory, with a mean score of 19.1. After completing the course, knowledge on cultural issues increased and was rated as very good and the mean score for all respondents was 26.9. Statistical analysis showed that there was statistical significance between the groups and the number of points achieved in the posttest. Respondents in the intervention group scored higher than those in the comparsion group.
The use of the graphic method, which is one of the forms of active learning, in teaching cultural content to nursing students has positive didactic effects. Students achieve better learning outcomes in terms of knowledge, skills and attitudes in a way that is more engaging. This makes learning difficult topics, such as a cultural issue, more effective. It would be worth considering using this method for other courses and/or at other universities as well.
漫画作为一种结合文字和图像的艺术形式,可以在教授护理学生方面取得巨大成功。教授多元文化问题的内容并不容易,特别是除了知识之外,还需要注意沟通技巧、尊重态度、开放或同理心等。如果没有学生的参与,就很难识别或讨论这些态度。漫画、连环漫画提供了这样的机会,并有助于学习新的内容,即使是那些难以自然和自发地沟通的内容。本文的目的是展示在护理教学中使用图形方法,特别是漫画和图形小说的可能性,以多元文化护理为例。
采用准实验干预研究,采用定量方法,以 STROBE 工具为指导。调查于 2022 年 3 月至 5 月在皮瓦应用科学大学的学生中进行。首先,评估学生对文化问题的了解,然后将他们随机分为两组。一组使用漫画书上课,另一组使用传统方法上课。课后再次评估学生的知识。采用描述性统计分析方法获得均值、中位数、标准差(SD)。数据遵循正态分布。使用 t-学生检验对独立组进行数据验证。
在参加课程之前,学生对文化问题的知识水平令人满意,平均得分为 19.1。完成课程后,对文化问题的了解增加,评价为非常好,所有受访者的平均得分为 26.9。统计分析显示,两组之间存在统计学意义,并且在后测中获得的分数也存在统计学意义。干预组的受访者得分高于对照组。
在教授护理学生文化内容时,使用图形方法,这是主动学习的一种形式,具有积极的教学效果。学生在知识、技能和态度方面的学习效果更好,更具吸引力。这使得学习文化问题等困难主题更加有效。值得考虑将这种方法用于其他课程和/或其他大学。