Sharma Anjana E, Khosla Kiran, Potharaju Kameswari, Mukherjea Arnab, Sarkar Urmimala
Department of Family and Community Medicine University of California San Francisco San Francisco, CA United States.
Center for Vulnerable Populations at Zuckerberg San Francisco General Hospital University of California San Francisco San Francisco, CA United States.
JMIR Infodemiology. 2023 Jan 5;3:e38607. doi: 10.2196/38607. eCollection 2023.
South Asians, inclusive of individuals originating in India, Pakistan, Maldives, Bangladesh, Sri Lanka, Bhutan, and Nepal, comprise the largest diaspora in the world, with large South Asian communities residing in the Caribbean, Africa, Europe, and elsewhere. There is evidence that South Asian communities have disproportionately experienced COVID-19 infections and mortality. WhatsApp, a free messaging app, is widely used in transnational communication within the South Asian diaspora. Limited studies exist on COVID-19-related misinformation specific to the South Asian community on WhatsApp. Understanding communication on WhatsApp may improve public health messaging to address COVID-19 disparities among South Asian communities worldwide.
We developed the COVID-19-Associated misinfoRmation On Messaging apps (CAROM) study to identify messages containing misinformation about COVID-19 shared via WhatsApp.
We collected messages forwarded globally through WhatsApp from self-identified South Asian community members between March 23 and June 3, 2021. We excluded messages that were in languages other than English, did not contain misinformation, or were not relevant to COVID-19. We deidentified each message and coded them for one or more content categories, media types (eg, video, image, text, web link, or a combination of these elements), and tone (eg, fearful, well intentioned, or pleading). We then performed a qualitative content analysis to arrive at key themes of COVID-19 misinformation.
We received 108 messages; 55 messages met the inclusion criteria for the final analytic sample; 32 (58%) contained text, 15 (27%) contained images, and 13 (24%) contained video. Content analysis revealed the following themes: "community transmission" relating to misinformation on how COVID-19 spreads in the community; "prevention" and "treatment," including Ayurvedic and traditional remedies for how to prevent or treat COVID-19 infection; and messaging attempting to sell "products or services" to prevent or cure COVID-19. Messages varied in audience from the general public to South Asians specifically; the latter included messages alluding to South Asian pride and solidarity. Scientific jargon and references to major organizations and leaders in health care were included to provide credibility. Messages with a pleading tone encouraged users to forward them to friends or family.
Misinformation in the South Asian community on WhatsApp spreads erroneous ideas regarding disease transmission, prevention, and treatment. Content evoking solidarity, "trustworthy" sources, and encouragement to forward messages may increase the spread of misinformation. Public health outlets and social media companies must actively combat misinformation to address health disparities among the South Asian diaspora during the COVID-19 pandemic and in future public health emergencies.
南亚人包括来自印度、巴基斯坦、马尔代夫、孟加拉国、斯里兰卡、不丹和尼泊尔的人,是世界上最大的侨民群体,在加勒比地区、非洲、欧洲和其他地方都有大量南亚社区。有证据表明,南亚社区感染新冠病毒和死亡的比例过高。WhatsApp是一款免费的即时通讯应用程序,在南亚侨民的跨国交流中被广泛使用。关于WhatsApp上特定于南亚社区的新冠病毒相关错误信息的研究有限。了解WhatsApp上的交流情况可能有助于改善公共卫生信息传递,以解决全球南亚社区之间的新冠病毒差异问题。
我们开展了“即时通讯应用程序上的新冠病毒相关错误信息”(CAROM)研究,以识别通过WhatsApp分享的包含关于新冠病毒错误信息的消息。
我们收集了2021年3月23日至6月3日期间全球范围内通过WhatsApp由自称是南亚社区成员转发的消息。我们排除了非英语语言的消息、不包含错误信息的消息或与新冠病毒无关的消息。我们对每条消息进行去识别处理,并为其编码一个或多个内容类别、媒体类型(如视频、图像、文本、网页链接或这些元素的组合)和语气(如恐惧、善意或恳求)。然后我们进行定性内容分析,以得出新冠病毒错误信息的关键主题。
我们收到了108条消息;55条消息符合最终分析样本的纳入标准;32条(58%)包含文本,15条(27%)包含图像,13条(24%)包含视频。内容分析揭示了以下主题:与新冠病毒在社区中传播方式的错误信息相关的“社区传播”;“预防”和“治疗”,包括关于如何预防或治疗新冠病毒感染的阿育吠陀和传统疗法;以及试图兜售预防或治愈新冠病毒的“产品或服务”的信息。消息的受众各不相同,从普通公众到特定的南亚人;后者包括暗示南亚自豪感和团结的消息。还包括科学术语以及对医疗保健领域主要组织和领导人的引用,以提供可信度。语气恳求的消息鼓励用户将其转发给朋友或家人。
南亚社区在WhatsApp上的错误信息传播了关于疾病传播、预防和治疗的错误观念。唤起团结、“可靠”来源以及鼓励转发消息的内容可能会增加错误信息的传播。公共卫生机构和社交媒体公司必须积极打击错误信息,以解决新冠疫情期间及未来公共卫生紧急情况中南亚侨民之间的健康差异问题。