Department Of Internal Medicine, Rochester General Hospital, Rochester, NY, United States.
Foundation for Research and Education in Endoscopy, Pune, India.
JMIR Public Health Surveill. 2021 Jan 30;7(1):e19858. doi: 10.2196/19858.
The risks of misinformation on social networking sites is a global issue, especially in light of the COVID-19 infodemic. WhatsApp is being used as an important source of COVID-19-related information during the current pandemic. Unlike Facebook and Twitter, limited studies have investigated the role of WhatsApp as a source of communication, information, or misinformation during crisis situations.
Our study aimed to evaluate the vulnerability of demographic cohorts in a developing country toward COVID-19-related misinformation shared via WhatsApp. We also aimed to identify characteristics of WhatsApp messages associated with increased credibility of misinformation.
We conducted a web-based questionnaire survey and designed a scoring system based on theories supported by the existing literature. Vulnerability (K) was measured as a ratio of the respondent's score to the maximum score. Respondents were stratified according to age and occupation, and K was calculated and compared among each subgroup using single-factor analysis of variance and Hochberg GT2 tests. The questionnaire evaluated the respondents' opinion of the veracity of coronavirus-related WhatsApp messages. The responses to the false-proven messages were compared using z test between the 2 groups: coronavirus-related WhatsApp messages with an attached link and/or source and those without.
We analyzed 1137 responses from WhatsApp users in India. Users aged over 65 years had the highest vulnerability (K=0.38, 95% CI 0.341-0.419) to misinformation. Respondents in the age group 19-25 years had significantly lower vulnerability (K=0.31, 95% CI 0.301-0.319) than those aged over 25 years (P<.05). The vulnerability of users employed in elementary occupations was the highest (K=0.38, 95% CI 0.356-0.404), and it was significantly higher than that of professionals and students (P<.05). Interestingly, the vulnerability of healthcare workers was not significantly different from that of other occupation groups (P>.05). We found that false CRWMs with an attached link and/or source were marked true 6 times more often than false CRWMs without an attached link or source (P<.001).
Our study demonstrates that in a developing country, WhatsApp users aged over 65 years and those involved in elementary occupations were found to be the most vulnerable to false information disseminated via WhatsApp. Health care workers, who are otherwise considered as experts with regard to this global health care crisis, also shared this vulnerability to misinformation with other occupation groups. Our findings also indicated that the presence of an attached link and/or source falsely validating an incorrect message adds significant false credibility, making it appear true. These results indicate an emergent need to address and rectify the current usage patterns of WhatsApp users. This study also provides metrics that can be used by health care organizations and government authorities of developing countries to formulate guidelines to contain the spread of WhatsApp-related misinformation.
社交网络网站上的错误信息风险是一个全球性问题,尤其是在 COVID-19 信息泛滥的情况下。在当前大流行期间,WhatsApp 被用作与 COVID-19 相关信息的重要来源。与 Facebook 和 Twitter 不同,很少有研究调查 WhatsApp 在危机情况下作为沟通、信息或错误信息来源的作用。
我们的研究旨在评估发展中国家的人口群体对通过 WhatsApp 共享的 COVID-19 相关错误信息的脆弱性。我们还旨在确定与错误信息可信度增加相关的 WhatsApp 消息特征。
我们进行了一项基于网络的问卷调查,并根据现有文献支持的理论设计了一个评分系统。脆弱性(K)作为受访者得分与最高得分的比率进行衡量。根据年龄和职业对受访者进行分层,使用单因素方差分析和 Hochberg GT2 检验在每个亚组中计算和比较 K。问卷评估了受访者对冠状病毒相关 WhatsApp 消息真实性的看法。通过 z 检验比较了两组之间的回复:带有链接和/或来源的冠状病毒相关 WhatsApp 消息与没有链接和/或来源的消息。
我们分析了来自印度 WhatsApp 用户的 1137 条回复。65 岁以上的用户对错误信息的脆弱性最高(K=0.38,95%CI 0.341-0.419)。年龄在 19-25 岁的受访者的脆弱性明显低于 25 岁以上的受访者(P<.05)。从事初级职业的用户的脆弱性最高(K=0.38,95%CI 0.356-0.404),明显高于专业人员和学生(P<.05)。有趣的是,医疗保健工作者的脆弱性与其他职业群体没有显著差异(P>.05)。我们发现,带有链接和/或来源的虚假 CRWMs 被标记为真实的可能性是没有链接或来源的虚假 CRWMs 的 6 倍(P<.001)。
我们的研究表明,在发展中国家,年龄在 65 岁以上和从事初级职业的 WhatsApp 用户被发现最容易受到通过 WhatsApp 传播的虚假信息的影响。医疗保健工作者在这场全球医疗保健危机中被视为专家,但他们也与其他职业群体一样容易受到错误信息的影响。我们的研究结果还表明,带有附加链接和/或来源的虚假验证错误消息会增加显著的虚假可信度,使其看起来是真实的。这些结果表明,迫切需要解决和纠正 WhatsApp 用户当前的使用模式。本研究还提供了可用于发展中国家的医疗保健组织和政府当局制定准则以遏制 WhatsApp 相关错误信息传播的指标。