Department of Hematology and Oncology, Miyagi Children's Hospital, Sendai, Japan.
Department of Hematology and Rheumatology, Nihon University Itabashi Hospital, Tokyo, Japan.
Lancet Haematol. 2023 Jun;10(6):e419-e432. doi: 10.1016/S2352-3026(23)00072-8. Epub 2023 May 8.
T-cell acute lymphoblastic leukaemia has distinct biological characteristics and a poorer prognosis than B-cell precursor acute lymphoblastic leukaemia. This trial aimed to reduce the rate of radiation and haematopoietic stem-cell transplantation (HSCT) while improving outcomes by adding nelarabine, intensified L-asparaginase, and protracted intrathecal therapy in the Berlin-Frankfurt-Münster (BFM)-type treatment.
In this nationwide, multicenter, phase 2 trial, we enrolled patients with newly diagnosed T-cell acute lymphoblastic leukaemia (age <25 years at diagnosis) conducted by Japan Children's Cancer Group and Japan Adult Leukemia Study Group. Patients were stratified into standard-risk, high-risk, and very-high-risk groups according to prednisolone response, CNS status, and end-of-consolidation minimal residual disease. We used the Associazione Italiana di Ematologia Oncologia Pediatrica (AIEOP)-BFM-ALL 2000-backbone chemotherapy. Nelarabine (650 mg/m per day for 5 days) was given to high-risk and very high-risk patients. All patients received, until the measurement of end-of-consolidation minimal residual disease, an identical therapy schedule, which included the prednisolone pre-phase remission induction therapy with dexamethasone (10 mg/m per day, for 3 weeks [for patients <10 years] or for 2 weeks including a 7-day off interval [for patients ≥10 years]) instead of prednisolone, and consolidation therapy added with Escherichia coli-derived L-asparaginase. On the basis of the stratification, patients received different intensities of treatment; L-asparaginase-intensified standard BFM-type therapy for standard risk and nelarabine-added high risk BFM-type therapy for high risk. In the very high-risk group, patients were randomly assigned (1:1) to group A (BFM-based block therapy) and group B (another block therapy, including high-dose dexamethasone) stratified by hospital, age (≥18 years or <18 years), and end-of-induction bone marrow blast percentage of M1 (<5%) or M2 (≥5%, <25%)+M3 (≥25%). Cranial radiotherapy was limited to patients with overt CNS disease at diagnosis (CNS3; >5 white blood cells per μL with blasts) and patients with no evidence of CNS disease received protracted triple intrathecal therapy. Only very high-risk patients were scheduled to receive HSCT. The primary endpoint was 3-year event-free survival for the entire cohort and the proportion of patients with disappearance of minimal residual disease between randomly assigned groups A and B in the very high-risk group. Secondary endpoints were overall survival, remission induction rate, and occurrence of adverse events. 3 years after the completion of patient accrual, a primary efficacy analysis was performed in the full analysis set and the per-protocol set. This study is registered with the Japan Registry of Clinical Trials, jRCTs041180145.
Between Dec 1, 2011, and Nov 30, 2017, of 349 eligible patients (median age 9 years [IQR 6-13]), 238 (68%) were male, and 28 (8%) patients had CNS3 status. 168 (48%) patients were stratified as standard risk, 103 (30%) as high risk, 39 (11%) as very high risk, and 39 (11%) as no risk (patients who had off protocol treatment before risk assessment. The composite complete remission (complete remission plus complete remission in suppression) rate after remission induction therapy was 89% (298 of 335 patients). HSCT was performed in 35 (10%) of 333 patients. With a median follow-up of 5·2 years (IQR 3·6-6·7), 3-year event-free survival was 86·4% (95% CI 82·3-89·7%) and 3-year overall survival was 91·3% (87·7-93·8%). The proportion of minimal residual disease disappearance was 0·86 (12 of 14 patients; 95% CI 0·57-0·98) in group A and 0·50 (6 of 12 patients, 0·21-0·79) in group B. Grade 3 peripheral motor neuropathy was seen in 11 (3%) of 349 patients and sensory neuropathy was seen in 6 (2%) patients. The most common grade 3 or worse adverse event was febrile neutropenia (294 [84%] of 349 patients). Treatment-related death occurred in three patients due to sepsis, gastric perforation, or intracranial haemorrhage during remission induction.
The ALL-T11 protocol produced encouraging outcomes with acceptable toxicities despite limited cranial radiotherapy and HSCT use.
Ministry of Health, Labor and Welfare of Japan, and Japan Agency for Medical Research and Development.
For the Japanese translation of the abstract see Supplementary Materials section.
T 细胞急性淋巴细胞白血病(T-cell acute lymphoblastic leukaemia,T-ALL)具有独特的生物学特征,其预后较 B 细胞前体急性淋巴细胞白血病(B-cell precursor acute lymphoblastic leukaemia,B-ALL)更差。本试验旨在通过增加奈拉滨、强化 L-天冬酰胺酶和延长鞘内治疗,降低放疗和造血干细胞移植(haematopoietic stem-cell transplantation,HSCT)的比例,改善治疗效果。
本研究为日本儿童癌症协会(Japan Children's Cancer Group)和日本成人白血病研究组(Japan Adult Leukemia Study Group)进行的一项全国性、多中心、2 期临床试验,纳入了新诊断为 T-ALL(诊断时年龄<25 岁)的患者。患者根据泼尼松龙反应、中枢神经系统(central nervous system,CNS)状态和巩固治疗结束时微小残留病(minimal residual disease,MRD)分为标准风险、高风险和极高风险组。我们采用意大利儿科血液肿瘤学会(Associazione Italiana di Ematologia Oncologia Pediatrica,AIEOP)-柏林-法兰克福-慕尼黑(Berlin-Frankfurt-Münster,BFM)-ALL 2000 方案作为基础化疗方案。高风险和极高风险患者接受奈拉滨(650 mg/m2,每天 5 天)治疗。所有患者在巩固治疗结束时检测 MRD 之前,均接受相同的治疗方案,包括泼尼松预诱导缓解治疗改为地塞米松(10 mg/m2,持续 3 周[<10 岁]或 2 周,包括 7 天停药间隔[≥10 岁])和添加大肠杆菌衍生的 L-天冬酰胺酶的巩固治疗。根据分层情况,患者接受不同强度的治疗;标准风险患者接受标准 BFM 型治疗加 L-天冬酰胺酶强化治疗,高风险患者接受奈拉滨联合高风险 BFM 型治疗。极高风险组患者按医院、年龄(≥18 岁或<18 岁)和诱导结束时骨髓 blast%(M1<5%或 M2≥5%、<25%+M3≥25%)分层,随机分为 A 组(BFM 基础阻断治疗)和 B 组(另一种阻断治疗,包括高剂量地塞米松)。诊断时有明显 CNS 疾病(CNS3;白细胞>5/μL,有 blast)的患者接受颅放疗,无 CNS 疾病证据的患者接受延长的三联鞘内治疗。仅极高风险患者计划接受 HSCT。主要终点是整个队列的 3 年无事件生存(event-free survival,EFS)和极高风险组中随机分配的 A 组和 B 组之间 MRD 消失的比例。次要终点是总生存(overall survival,OS)、缓解诱导率和不良事件的发生。患者入组 3 年后,在全分析集和方案符合集进行了主要疗效分析。本研究在日本临床试验注册中心(jRCTs041180145)注册。
2011 年 12 月 1 日至 2017 年 11 月 30 日,共有 349 例符合条件的患者(中位年龄 9 岁[四分位距 6-13]),其中 238 例(68%)为男性,28 例(8%)患者有 CNS3 状态。168 例(48%)患者为标准风险,103 例(30%)为高风险,39 例(11%)为极高风险,39 例(11%)为无风险(在风险评估前有方案外治疗的患者)。缓解诱导治疗后完全缓解(包括完全缓解+缓解抑制)率为 89%(335 例患者中的 298 例)。333 例患者中有 35 例(10%)接受了 HSCT。中位随访 5.2 年(四分位距 3.6-6.7),3 年 EFS 为 86.4%(95%CI 82.3-89.7%),3 年 OS 为 91.3%(87.7-93.8%)。A 组 MRD 消失率为 0.86(12 例患者中的 14 例;95%CI 0.57-0.98),B 组为 0.50(12 例患者中的 6 例,0.21-0.79)。349 例患者中 3 例(3%)出现 3 级周围运动神经病,6 例(2%)出现感觉神经病。最常见的 3 级或以上不良事件是发热性中性粒细胞减少症(349 例患者中的 294 例,84%)。3 例患者因败血症、胃穿孔或缓解诱导期间的颅内出血而死亡。
尽管放疗和 HSCT 的应用有限,ALL-T11 方案仍产生了令人鼓舞的结果,具有可接受的毒性。
日本厚生劳动省和日本医疗研究与发展署。