Fubini A, Cecchi E, Spinnler M T, Di Leo M, Bergerone S, Orzan F, Presbitero P, Morello P, Castellano G, Turco G
Br Heart J. 1986 Jun;55(6):535-42. doi: 10.1136/hrt.55.6.535.
Sixty consecutive patients who were symptom free 2-12 months after an uncomplicated acute myocardial infarction underwent maximal treadmill exercise testing, radionuclide angiography before and during submaximal bicycle stress test, and coronary angiography. The results of the non-invasive procedures were compared with those of coronary angiography. The sensitivity and specificity of electrocardiogram stress test for detection of multivessel disease were 40% and 77% respectively. Failure of left ventricular ejection fraction to increase at least 5% with exercise identified 20 of the 25 patients with multivessel disease (sensitivity 80%) and 23 of the 35 patients with no additional coronary artery stenosis (specificity 66%). In patients with anterior Q waves the sensitivity was 78% and the specificity 50%, whereas in the presence of inferior Q waves these values were 81% and 87% respectively. Loss of left ventricle synchronicity during effort, as indicated by failure of the standard deviation of the phases to decrease during exercise, demonstrated a radionuclide angiography sensitivity of 80% (77% for anterior myocardial infarction and 81% for inferior myocardial infarction) and a specificity of 50% (33% for anterior myocardial infarction and 64% for inferior myocardial infarction). When the test was considered to be positive if either the ejection fraction or the standard deviation of the phases criteria were positive, the sensitivity was 100% and specificity 46% (30% for anterior myocardial infarction and 65% for inferior myocardial infarction). It is concluded that in patients who are free from angina 2-12 months after an episode of uncomplicated myocardial infarction, a simple exercise electrocardiogram cannot be relied upon to detect residual ischaemia. An abnormal ejection fraction response or an increased standard deviation of the phases during exercise nuclear angiography or both identified all the patients with multivessel disease. None of the patients in whom radionuclide angiographic criteria were negative had multivessel disease.
60例在无并发症急性心肌梗死后2至12个月无症状的连续患者接受了极量平板运动试验、次极量踏车运动试验前及试验期间的放射性核素血管造影以及冠状动脉造影。将无创检查结果与冠状动脉造影结果进行比较。心电图运动试验检测多支血管病变的敏感性和特异性分别为40%和77%。运动时左心室射血分数未能至少增加5%可识别出25例多支血管病变患者中的20例(敏感性80%)以及35例无额外冠状动脉狭窄患者中的23例(特异性66%)。在前壁Q波患者中,敏感性为78%,特异性为50%;而在下壁Q波患者中,这些值分别为81%和87%。运动时左心室同步性丧失,表现为运动期间相位标准差未能降低,放射性核素血管造影的敏感性为80%(前壁心肌梗死为77%,下壁心肌梗死为81%),特异性为50%(前壁心肌梗死为33%,下壁心肌梗死为64%)。如果射血分数或相位标准差标准中有一项为阳性则将试验视为阳性,此时敏感性为100%,特异性为46%(前壁心肌梗死为30%,下壁心肌梗死为65%)。得出的结论是,在无并发症心肌梗死发作后2至12个月无心绞痛的患者中,单纯的运动心电图不能可靠地检测残余缺血。运动核素血管造影期间异常的射血分数反应或相位标准差增加或两者均存在可识别出所有多支血管病变患者。放射性核素血管造影标准为阴性的患者中无一例有多支血管病变。