Bright Tess, Ramke Jacqueline, Zhang Justine H, Kitema Gatera Fiston, Safi Sare, Mdala Shaffi, Yoshizaki Miho, Brennan-Jones Christopher G, Mactaggart Islay, Gordon Iris, Swenor Bonnielin K, Burton Matthew J, Evans Jennifer R
Indigenous Health Equity Unit, Centre for Health Equity, University of Melbourne, Melbourne, Australia.
International Centre for Eye Health, London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine, London, United Kingdom.
PLOS Glob Public Health. 2023 May 16;3(5):e0001905. doi: 10.1371/journal.pgph.0001905. eCollection 2023.
Hearing and vision impairments are common globally. They are often considered separately in research, and in planning and delivering services. However, they can occur concurrently, termed dual sensory impairment (DSI). The prevalence and impact of hearing and vision impairment have been well-examined, but there has been much less consideration of DSI. The aim of this scoping review was to determine the nature and extent of the evidence on prevalence and impact of DSI. Three databases were searched: MEDLINE, Embase and Global Health (April 2022). We included primary studies and systematic reviews reporting the prevalence or impact of DSI. No limits were placed on age, publication dates, or country. Only studies where the full text was available in English were included. Two reviewers independently screened titles, abstract, full texts. Data were charted by two reviewers independently using a pre-piloted form. The review identified 183 reports of 153 unique primary studies and 14 review articles. Most evidence came from high-income countries (86% of reports). Prevalence varied across reports, as did age groups of participants and definitions used. The prevalence of DSI increased with age. Impact was examined across three broad groups of outcomes-psychosocial, participation, and physical health. There was a strong trend towards poorer outcomes for people with DSI across all categories compared to people with one or neither impairment, including activities of daily living (worse for people with DSI in 78% of reports) and depression (68%). This scoping review highlights that DSI is a relatively common condition with substantial impact, particularly among older adults. There is a gap in evidence from low and middle-income countries. There is a pressing need for a consensus position on the definition(s) of DSI and standardisation of reporting age groups to enable reliable estimates to be ascertained and compared and responsive services developed.
听力和视力障碍在全球范围内都很常见。在研究以及规划和提供服务时,它们通常被分开考虑。然而,它们可能同时出现,称为双重感官障碍(DSI)。听力和视力障碍的患病率及影响已得到充分研究,但对双重感官障碍的关注要少得多。本范围综述的目的是确定关于双重感官障碍患病率及影响的证据的性质和范围。我们检索了三个数据库:MEDLINE、Embase和Global Health(2022年4月)。我们纳入了报告双重感官障碍患病率或影响的原始研究和系统评价。对年龄、出版日期或国家没有限制。仅纳入全文为英文的研究。两名评审员独立筛选标题、摘要和全文。两名评审员使用预先试用的表格独立绘制数据。该综述确定了153项独特原始研究的183份报告以及14篇综述文章。大多数证据来自高收入国家(86%的报告)。不同报告中的患病率各不相同,参与者的年龄组和所用定义也有所不同。双重感官障碍的患病率随年龄增长而增加。从心理社会、参与和身体健康三大类结果对影响进行了研究。与有一项或没有障碍的人相比,双重感官障碍患者在所有类别中的结果都明显更差,包括日常生活活动(78%的报告显示双重感官障碍患者情况更差)和抑郁症(68%)。本范围综述强调,双重感官障碍是一种相对常见且影响重大的状况,尤其是在老年人中。低收入和中等收入国家的证据存在差距。迫切需要就双重感官障碍的定义达成共识,并对报告年龄组进行标准化,以便能够确定和比较可靠的估计数,并制定相应的服务。