Centre for Proper Housing of Ruminants and Pigs, Federal Food Safety and Veterinary Office, Agroscope, Ettenhausen, Switzerland.
Ruminant Research Group, Agroscope, Posieux, Switzerland.
PLoS One. 2023 May 18;18(5):e0285933. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0285933. eCollection 2023.
Monitoring the feeding and ruminating behaviour of ruminants can be used to assess their health and welfare. The MSR-jaw movement recording system (JAM-R) can automatically record the jaw movements of ruminants. The associated software Viewer2 was developed to classify these recordings in adult cattle and calculate the duration and number of mastications of feeding and ruminating. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the performance of Viewer2 in classifying the behaviour of sheep and goats and assessing their feeding and ruminating. The feeding and ruminating behaviour of ten sheep and ten goats on pasture (observed live) and of five sheep and five goats in the barn (observed by video) were compared with Viewer2 behaviour classifications. To assess the technical and welfare issues of the JAM-R, its application was tested in a feeding experiment with 24 h monitoring of the feeding behaviours of 24 sheep and 24 goats. Viewer2 worked equally well on both species. The mean (95% confidence interval) performance of Viewer2 was at a good level for feeding (accuracy: 0.8-1.0; sensitivity: 0.9-1.0; specificity: 0.6-0.9; precision: 0.7-0.9) and ruminating (accuracy: 0.8-0.9; sensitivity: 0.6-0.8; specificity: 0.8-1.0; precision: 0.9-1.0) compared with human observations, with minor differences between the conditions on pasture and in the barn. The performance improved when recording frequency was increased from 10 Hz to 20 Hz. Applying the JAM-R in a feeding experiment, 71% of the recordings executed were defined as technically error-free and produced plausible values for feeding behaviours. In conclusion, according to the values of accuracy, sensitivity, specificity and precision, the presented JAM-R system with Viewer2 is a reliable and applicable technology for automatic recording of feeding and ruminating behaviour of sheep and goats on pasture and in the barn.
监测反刍动物的进食和反刍行为可用于评估其健康和福利。MSR-下颌运动记录系统(JAM-R)可以自动记录反刍动物的下颌运动。开发相关软件 Viewer2 是为了对成年牛的这些记录进行分类,并计算进食和反刍的咀嚼次数和时长。本研究旨在评估 Viewer2 对绵羊和山羊行为分类的性能,并评估其进食和反刍情况。通过与 Viewer2 行为分类进行比较,评估了 pasture(现场观察)上 10 只绵羊和 10 只山羊以及 barn(视频观察)中 5 只绵羊和 5 只山羊的进食和反刍行为。为了评估 JAM-R 的技术和福利问题,对其进行了 24 小时监测 24 只绵羊和 24 只山羊进食行为的饲养实验应用测试。Viewer2 在两种物种上的表现都同样出色。对于进食(准确度:0.8-1.0;灵敏度:0.9-1.0;特异性:0.6-0.9;精密度:0.7-0.9)和反刍(准确度:0.8-0.9;灵敏度:0.6-0.8;特异性:0.8-1.0;精密度:0.9-1.0),Viewer2 的平均性能(95%置信区间)处于良好水平,与 pasture 和 barn 条件下的人类观察结果相比,差异较小。当记录频率从 10 Hz 增加到 20 Hz 时,性能会提高。在饲养实验中应用 JAM-R,71%的记录被定义为技术上无错误,并产生了对进食行为的合理值。总之,根据准确度、灵敏度、特异性和精密度的值,所介绍的带有 Viewer2 的 JAM-R 系统是一种可靠且适用的技术,可用于自动记录 pasture 和 barn 中绵羊和山羊的进食和反刍行为。