School of Computer Science, Jubilee Campus, Wollaton Road, Nottingham, NG8 1BB, UK.
Centre for Computing and Social Responsibility, De Montfort University, The Gateway, Leicester, LE19BH, UK.
Sci Rep. 2023 May 18;13(1):7586. doi: 10.1038/s41598-023-34622-w.
Intelligent systems that are capable of making autonomous decisions based on input from their environment have great potential to do good, but they also raise significant social and ethical concerns. The discourse on ethics and artificial intelligence (AI) has covered these concerns in depth and developed an array of possible ways of addressing them. This article argues that a shortcoming of this discourse is that it concentrates on specific issues and their mitigation but neglects the nature of intelligent systems as socio-technical systems of systems that are often described as ecosystems. Building on the discussion of ethics and AI, the article suggests that it would be beneficial to come to an understanding of what would constitute responsible AI ecosystems. By introducing the concept of meta-responsibility or higher-level responsibility, the article proposes characteristics that an ecosystem would have to fulfil, in order to be considered a responsible ecosystem. This perspective is theoretically interesting because it extends the current AI ethics discourse. It furthermore offers a novel perspective for researchers and developers of intelligent system and helps them reflect on the way they relate to ethical issues.
能够根据环境输入做出自主决策的智能系统具有巨大的潜力,但也引发了重大的社会和伦理问题。关于伦理和人工智能(AI)的讨论已经深入探讨了这些问题,并提出了一系列可能的解决方法。本文认为,这一讨论的一个缺点是,它集中讨论了特定问题及其缓解措施,但忽略了智能系统作为通常被描述为生态系统的社会技术系统的性质。本文基于对伦理和 AI 的讨论,提出了一个观点,即理解什么是负责任的 AI 生态系统将是有益的。通过引入元责任或更高层次责任的概念,本文提出了一个生态系统必须满足的特征,以便被认为是一个负责任的生态系统。这种观点在理论上很有趣,因为它扩展了当前的 AI 伦理讨论。此外,它为智能系统的研究人员和开发人员提供了一个新的视角,并帮助他们反思他们与伦理问题的关系方式。