Cuff Andrew, Jesson Thomas, Yeowell Gillian, Dikomitis Lisa, Foster Nadine E, Littlewood Chris
Faculty of Health, Psychology and Social Care, Manchester Metropolitan University, Brooks Building, 53 Bonsall Street, M15 6GX, UK.
Connect Health, The Light Box, Quorum Business Park, Benton Lane, Newcastle-upon-Tyne, NE13 8EU, UK.
PEC Innov. 2022 Apr 19;1:100040. doi: 10.1016/j.pecinn.2022.100040. eCollection 2022 Dec.
To describe and synthesise the content of public-facing websites regarding the use of diagnostic imaging for adults with lower back pain, knee, and shoulder pain.
Scoping review conducted in accordance with PRISMA guidance. A Google search was performed to identify public-facing websites that were either United Kingdom-based, or National Health Service affiliated. The DISCERN tool was used to appraise website quality before information regarding the use of imaging was synthesised using thematic analysis.
Eighty-six websites were included, with 48 making reference to the use of imaging. The information within the majority (n = 43) of public-facing websites aligns with best available evidence. Where there is inconsistency, this may be explained by lower website quality. Three themes were apparent regarding the use of imaging - imaging to inform diagnosis and management; imaging in context; patient experience and expectations.
The recommendations and rationale for use of imaging contained within public-facing websites does not appear to justify the increase in imaging rates for musculoskeletal pain in the UK.
Publicly available information following a novel search strategy, is largely aligned with best evidence, further understanding is required to determine reasons for requesting imaging from a patient and clinician perspective.
描述并综合面向公众的网站中关于成人下背痛、膝关节痛和肩痛诊断性成像使用情况的内容。
按照PRISMA指南进行范围综述。通过谷歌搜索,识别以英国为基地或隶属于国民保健服务体系的面向公众的网站。在使用主题分析法综合有关成像使用的信息之前,使用DISCERN工具评估网站质量。
纳入了86个网站,其中48个提及成像的使用。大多数(n = 43)面向公众的网站中的信息与现有最佳证据一致。在存在不一致的地方,这可能是由于网站质量较低所致。关于成像的使用有三个明显的主题——用于辅助诊断和管理的成像;特定背景下的成像;患者体验和期望。
面向公众的网站中关于成像使用的建议和基本原理似乎无法解释英国肌肉骨骼疼痛成像率的上升。
采用新颖的搜索策略获取的公开可用信息在很大程度上与最佳证据一致,需要进一步了解从患者和临床医生角度要求进行成像检查的原因。