Respiratory Health Division, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, Morgantown, West Virginia, USA.
Division of Vector-Borne Diseases, National Center for Emerging and Zoonotic Infectious Diseases, Fort Collins, Colorado, USA.
Am J Ind Med. 2023 Aug;66(8):655-669. doi: 10.1002/ajim.23488. Epub 2023 May 23.
Sporicidal products containing hydrogen peroxide (HP), peracetic acid (PAA), and acetic acid (AA) are used widely in multiple industries, including healthcare. Despite widespread use in healthcare, few studies have assessed associations between exposures to HP, PAA, and AA, and work-related symptoms in these settings.
In 2018, we performed a health and exposure assessment at a hospital where a sporicidal product consisting of HP, PAA, and AA, was used as the primary cleaner on hospital surfaces. We collected 56 personal and mobile air samples for HP, PAA, and AA on participants while they performed their regular cleaning duties; collected area samples for HP (n = 28), PAA (n = 28), and AA (n = 70) in multiple hospital locations where cleaning was performed; and administered a postshift survey to assess eye, skin, and upper and lower airway symptoms that occurred cross-shift or in the previous 4 weeks.
Full-shift exposure levels for HP (range: <3-559 ppb), PAA (range: <0.2-8 ppb), and AA (range: <5-915 ppb) were all below US occupational exposure limits. We observed positive associations (p < 0.05) between shift, departmental average, and departmental 95th percentile exposures to HP, PAA, and AA vapors, and work-related acute (cross-shift) and chronic (previous 4 weeks) eye, upper airway, and lower airway symptoms after adjusting for age, gender, smoking status, use of other cleaning products containing sensitizers and irritants, allergic status, and stress.
Our observations of work-related upper and lower airway symptoms among hospital workers exposed to vapors from a sporicidal product containing HP, PAA, and AA indicate a need for a combination of engineering, administrative, and PPE controls to reduce exposure. Additionally, alternative nonchemical disinfection technologies should be further investigated as a means to simultaneously reduce healthcare workers' exposure to disinfectants while also minimizing costly healthcare-acquired infections.
含过氧化氢(HP)、过氧乙酸(PAA)和乙酸(AA)的杀菌产品广泛应用于多个行业,包括医疗保健行业。尽管在医疗保健领域广泛使用,但很少有研究评估在这些环境中接触 HP、PAA 和 AA 与工作相关症状之间的关系。
2018 年,我们在一家医院进行了一项健康和暴露评估,该医院使用由 HP、PAA 和 AA 组成的杀菌产品作为医院表面的主要清洁剂。我们在参与者执行日常清洁任务时收集了 56 份个人和移动空气样本,用于检测 HP、PAA 和 AA;在进行清洁的多个医院地点收集了 HP(n=28)、PAA(n=28)和 AA(n=70)的区域样本;并在轮班后进行了问卷调查,以评估跨班次或过去 4 周内发生的眼部、皮肤和上、下呼吸道症状。
HP(范围:<3-559 ppb)、PAA(范围:<0.2-8 ppb)和 AA(范围:<5-915 ppb)的全班次暴露水平均低于美国职业接触限值。我们观察到 HP、PAA 和 AA 蒸气的轮班、部门平均和部门 95 百分位数暴露与工作相关的急性(跨班次)和慢性(过去 4 周)眼部、上呼吸道和下呼吸道症状之间存在正相关(p<0.05),调整年龄、性别、吸烟状况、使用其他含致敏剂和刺激性的清洁剂、过敏状况和压力因素后。
我们观察到接触含有 HP、PAA 和 AA 的杀菌产品蒸气的医院工作人员出现与工作相关的上、下呼吸道症状,这表明需要结合工程、管理和个人防护装备控制措施来降低暴露水平。此外,还应进一步研究替代非化学消毒技术,以减少医护人员接触消毒剂,同时尽量减少昂贵的医院获得性感染。