Gärdenfors Moa, Johansson Victoria
Department of Linguistics, Faculty of Humanities, Stockholm University, Stockholm, Sweden.
Department of Primary Teacher Education, Faculty of Education, Kristianstad University, Kristianstad, Sweden.
Front Psychol. 2023 May 9;14:1112263. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2023.1112263. eCollection 2023.
The small body of research on writing and writing processes in the group of deaf and hard of hearing (DHH) children has shown that this group struggles more with writing than their hearing peers. This article aims to explore in what ways the DHH group differs from their peers regarding the written product and the writing processes. Participants are all in the age span 10-12 years old and include: (a) 12 DHH children with knowledge of Swedish sign language (Svenskt teckenspråk, STS) as well as spoken Swedish, (b) 10 age-matched hearing children of deaf adults (CODA) who know STS, (c) 14 age-matched hearing peers with no STS knowledge. More specifically we investigate how text length and lexical properties relate to writing processes such as planning (measured through pauses) and revision, and how the background factors of age, gender, hearing and knowledge of STS predict the outcome in product and process. The data consists of picture-elicited narratives collected with keystroke logging. The overall results show that age is a strong predictor for writing fluency, longer texts and more sophisticated lexicon for all the children. This confirms theories on writing development which stress that when children have automatized basic low-level processes such as transcription and spelling, this will free up cognitive space for engaging in high-level processes, such as planning and revision-which in turn will result in more mature texts. What characterizes the DHH group is slower writing fluency, higher lexical density, due to omitted function words, and extensive revisions (both deletions and insertions) on word level and below. One explanation for the last finding is that limitations in the auditory input lead to more uncertainty regarding correct and appropriate lexical choices, as well as spelling. The article contributes with more specific knowledge on what is challenging during writing for DHH children with knowledge of STS and spoken Swedish in middle school, in the developmental stage when basic writing skills are established.
关于聋哑和重听(DHH)儿童写作及写作过程的少量研究表明,该群体在写作方面比听力正常的同龄人面临更多困难。本文旨在探讨DHH群体在书面作品和写作过程方面与同龄人有何不同。参与者均为10至12岁的儿童,包括:(a)12名既懂瑞典手语(Svenskt teckenspråk,STS)又会说瑞典语的DHH儿童;(b)10名年龄匹配、懂STS的聋人成年人的听力正常子女(CODA);(c)14名年龄匹配、不懂STS的听力正常同龄人。更具体地说,我们研究文本长度和词汇特性如何与诸如计划(通过停顿来衡量)和修改等写作过程相关,以及年龄、性别、听力和STS知识等背景因素如何预测作品和过程的结果。数据包括通过按键记录收集的图片引发的叙述。总体结果表明,年龄是所有儿童写作流畅性、更长文本和更复杂词汇的有力预测因素。这证实了关于写作发展的理论,即当儿童将转录和拼写等基本低级过程自动化时,这将释放认知空间以参与高级过程,如计划和修改,进而产生更成熟的文本。DHH群体的特点是写作流畅性较慢、由于功能词省略导致词汇密度较高,以及在单词层面及以下进行大量修改(包括删除和插入)。对最后一个发现的一种解释是,听觉输入的限制导致在正确和合适的词汇选择以及拼写方面存在更多不确定性。本文提供了更具体的知识,说明在中学阶段,对于既懂STS又会说瑞典语的DHH儿童来说,在基本写作技能建立的发展阶段,写作过程中存在哪些挑战。