Joint Division of Clinical Epidemiology, Affilated Hosptial of Nantong University, School of Public Health of Nantong University, Nantong, Jiangsu, China.
Division of Health Policy and Management, University of Minnesota Twin Cities, Minneapolis, Minnesota, USA.
BMJ Glob Health. 2023 May;8(5). doi: 10.1136/bmjgh-2023-012306.
Given the ageing epidemic of tuberculosis (TB), China is facing an unprecedented opportunity provided by the first clinically approved next-generation TB vaccine Vaccae, which demonstrated 54.7% efficacy for preventing reactivation from latent infection in a phase III trial. We aim to assess the population-level health and economic impacts of introducing Vaccae vaccination to inform policy-makers.
We evaluated a potential national Vaccae vaccination programme in China initiated in 2024, assuming 20 years of protection, 90% coverage and US$30/dose government contract price. An age-structured compartmental model was adapted to simulate three strategies: (1) no Vaccae; (2) mass vaccination among people aged 15-74 years and (3) targeted vaccination among older adults (60 years). Cost analyses were conducted from the healthcare sector perspective, discounted at 3%.
Considering postinfection efficacy, targeted vaccination modestly reduced TB burden (~20%), preventing cumulative 8.01 (95% CI 5.82 to 11.8) million TB cases and 0.20 (0.17 to 0.26) million deaths over 2024-2050, at incremental cost-effectiveness ratio of US$4387 (2218 to 10 085) per disability adjusted life year averted. The implementation would require a total budget of US$22.5 (17.6 to 43.4) billion. In contrast, mass vaccination had a larger bigger impact on the TB epidemic, but the overall costs remained high. Although both preinfection and postinfection vaccine efficacy type might have a maximum impact (>40% incidence rate reduction in 2050), it is important that the vaccine price does not exceed US$5/dose.
Vaccae represents a robust and cost-effective choice for TB epidemic control in China. This study may facilitate the practice of evidence-based strategy plans for TB vaccination and reimbursement decision making.
鉴于结核病(TB)的老龄化流行,中国正面临着首个经临床批准的下一代结核病疫苗 Vaccae 带来的前所未有的机遇,该疫苗在 III 期临床试验中显示出 54.7%的预防潜伏感染复发的功效。我们旨在评估引入 Vaccae 疫苗接种对人群健康和经济的影响,为决策者提供信息。
我们评估了假设在 2024 年开始的中国全国范围内的潜在 Vaccae 疫苗接种计划,保护期为 20 年,覆盖率为 90%,政府合同价为 30 美元/剂。我们采用了一个年龄结构的隔室模型来模拟三种策略:(1)不接种 Vaccae;(2)对 15-74 岁人群进行大规模接种;(3)对老年人(60 岁)进行目标接种。成本分析从医疗保健部门的角度进行,贴现率为 3%。
考虑到感染后功效,目标接种策略适度降低了结核病负担(~20%),在 2024-2050 年期间预防了 801 万(95%CI 582 万至 1180 万)例结核病病例和 20 万(17 万至 26 万)例死亡,增量成本效益比为每避免一个残疾调整生命年的 4387 美元(2218 美元至 10085 美元)。实施该计划需要总共 225 亿美元(176 亿至 434 亿美元)的预算。相比之下,大规模接种对结核病流行有更大的影响,但总体成本仍然很高。尽管预感染和感染后疫苗功效类型都可能产生最大的影响(2050 年发病率降低超过 40%),但疫苗价格不超过 5 美元/剂非常重要。
Vaccae 是中国结核病流行控制的有力且具有成本效益的选择。本研究可能有助于结核病疫苗接种的循证策略计划和报销决策的实践。