Kotzmann Jane
Alfred Deakin Postdoctoral Research Fellow in Law, Deakin University Law School, Melbourne, Victoria, Australia.
Oxf J Leg Stud. 2023 Feb 18;43(2):405-428. doi: 10.1093/ojls/gqad003. eCollection 2023 Summer.
To date, welfare protections have failed animals. In this context, many animal advocates and scholars have supported recognition of animal rights. Animal rights theory, however, remains underdeveloped. This article contributes to the development of animal rights theory and, in this respect, proposes the utilisation of sentience and intrinsic worth concepts as a pluralist foundation for prospective animal rights. Sentience and intrinsic worth as a conceptual underpinning for animal rights hold clear benefits in that (i) the concepts are already embedded in many legal systems, (ii) sentience would enable the development of animal rights to be built on the established interest theory of rights, and (iii) sentience directly links to the justification of rights as being primarily concerned with the prevention of pain and suffering.
迄今为止,福利保护未能惠及动物。在此背景下,许多动物权益倡导者和学者支持承认动物权利。然而,动物权利理论仍不完善。本文有助于动物权利理论的发展,并在这方面提议将感知能力和固有价值概念用作未来动物权利的多元主义基础。将感知能力和固有价值作为动物权利的概念基础具有明显益处,即:(i)这些概念已融入许多法律体系;(ii)感知能力能使动物权利的发展建立在既定的权利利益理论之上;(iii)感知能力直接与权利的正当性相联系,因为权利主要关乎预防痛苦和苦难。