Ben Yair Yitzhak, Hoch Liron
The Department of Behavioral Science, Zefat Academic College, 11 Jerusalem St., P.O.B 160, Zefat, Israel.
The Department of Interdisciplinary Studies, Zefat Academic College, Zefat, Israel.
J Relig Health. 2024 Aug;63(4):2690-2708. doi: 10.1007/s10943-023-01846-z. Epub 2023 Jun 8.
Traditional religious and spiritual texts offer a surprising wealth of relevant theoretical and practical knowledge about human behavior. This wellspring may contribute significantly to expanding our current body of knowledge in the social sciences, and criminology in particular. In Jewish religious texts, specifically by Maimonides, we can find profound analyses of human traits and guidelines for a normative way of life. Among other things, modern criminological literature attempts to link certain character traits and divergent behaviors. Using the hermeneutic phenomenological approach, this present study analyzed Maimonidean writings, mainly Laws of Human Dispositions, in order to understand Moses ben Maimon (1138-1204) and his view of character traits. The analysis yielded four themes: (1) Human personality between nature and nurture; (2) The complexity of human personality, imbalance and criminality; (3) Extremism as a way to achieve balance; and (4) The Middle Way, flexibility and common sense. These themes can serve therapeutic purposes, as well as inform a rehabilitation model. Grounded in a theoretical rationale about the nature of humans, this model is designed to direct individuals to balance their traits by self-reflection and constant practice of the Middle Way. The article concludes by proposing that implementing this model may promote normative behavior and thus contribute to rehabilitating offenders.
传统宗教和精神文本提供了关于人类行为的丰富理论和实践知识,令人惊讶。这一知识源泉可能对扩展我们目前社会科学领域的知识体系,尤其是犯罪学知识体系,做出重大贡献。在犹太宗教文本中,特别是迈蒙尼德的著作里,我们能找到对人类特质的深刻分析以及规范生活方式的指导原则。现代犯罪学文献试图将某些性格特质与不同行为联系起来。本研究采用诠释现象学方法,分析了迈蒙尼德的著作,主要是《人类性情律法》,以了解摩西·本·迈蒙(1138 - 1204)及其对性格特质的看法。分析得出了四个主题:(1)人类个性中的天性与教养;(2)人类个性的复杂性、失衡与犯罪;(3)极端主义作为实现平衡的一种方式;(4)中庸之道、灵活性与常识。这些主题可用于治疗目的,也能为康复模式提供参考。基于关于人类本性的理论依据,该模式旨在引导个人通过自我反思和持续践行中庸之道来平衡自身特质。文章最后提出,实施这一模式可能促进规范行为,从而有助于改造罪犯。