Schwartz Elka, Guidry Kathryn, Lee Amanda, Dinh Danny, Levin Mindy F, Demers Marika
School of Physical and Occupational Therapy, McGill University, Montreal, Quebec, Canada.
Centre Intégré de Santé et Services Sociaux de Laval-Jewish Rehabilitation Hospital, Centre for Interdisciplinary Research in Rehabilitation, Laval, Quebec, Canada.
Physiother Can. 2022 Aug 24;74(4):387-395. doi: 10.3138/ptc-2021-0025. eCollection 2022 Nov.
This scoping review aimed to identify which clinical tests are used to assess upper limb, lower limb, and trunk motor coordination, and their metric and measurement properties for adult neurological populations. MEDLINE (1946-) and EMBASE (1996-) databases were searched using keywords such as movement quality, motor performance, motor coordination, assessment, and psychometrics. Data regarding the body part assessed, neurological condition, psychometric properties, and scored metrics of spatial and/or temporal coordination were independently extracted by two reviewers. Alternate versions of some tests such as the Finger-to-Nose Test were included. Fifty-one included articles yielded 2 tests measuring spatial coordination, 7 tests measuring temporal coordination, and 10 tests measuring both. Scoring metrics and measurement properties differed between tests, with a majority of tests having good-to-excellent measurement properties. The metrics of motor coordination scored by current tests vary. Since tests do not assess functional task performance, the onus falls on clinicians to infer the connection between coordination impairments and functional deficits. Clinical practice would benefit from the development of a battery of tests that assesses the metrics of coordination related to functional performance.
本综述旨在确定用于评估成人神经疾病患者上肢、下肢和躯干运动协调性的临床测试,以及这些测试的指标和测量特性。使用运动质量、运动表现、运动协调、评估和心理测量学等关键词检索了MEDLINE(1946年起)和EMBASE(1996年起)数据库。两名评审员独立提取了有关评估的身体部位、神经疾病、心理测量特性以及空间和/或时间协调性的评分指标的数据。纳入了一些测试的替代版本,如指鼻试验。51篇纳入文章产生了2项测量空间协调性的测试、7项测量时间协调性的测试以及10项同时测量两者的测试。不同测试的评分指标和测量特性有所不同,大多数测试具有良好到优秀的测量特性。当前测试所评分的运动协调指标各不相同。由于测试不评估功能性任务表现,临床医生有责任推断协调障碍与功能缺陷之间的联系。开发一套评估与功能表现相关的协调指标的测试将有益于临床实践。