Proano Ana Cristina, Viteri Javier A, Orozco Eileen N, Calle Marco Antonio, Costa Stefany Carolina, Reyes Daniel V, German-Montenegro Melissa, Moncayo David F, Tobar Andrea C, Moncayo Juan A
School of Medicine, Universidad Internacional del Ecuador, Quito 170411, Ecuador.
School of Medicine, Colegio de Ciencias de la Salud, Universidad San Francisco de Quito, Cumbayá 170901, Ecuador.
Neurol Int. 2023 Jun 13;15(2):750-763. doi: 10.3390/neurolint15020047.
(1) Background: Parkinson's disease (PD) is a relatively common and complex pathology, and some of its mechanisms remain to be elucidated. Change in host microbiota is related to the pathophysiology of numerous diseases. This systematic review aims to gather existing data on the occidental hemisphere, compare it, and search for any significant association between Parkinson's disease and gut microbiota dysbiosis. (2) Methods: Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis (PRISMA) and Meta-analyses Of Observational Studies in Epidemiology (MOOSE) protocols were used for this systematic review. PubMed was used as the database search engine. Of the 166 studies found, only 10 were used, as they met our inclusion criteria: case-control studies, studies that assessed the correlation of PD and gut microbiome, studies that took place in occidental regions, and studies that were performed on humans and were written in English. The Newcastle-Ottawa Scale was used as the assessment tool for overall risk of bias in this systematic review. (3) Results: The studies analyzed were divided into three geographic areas: Region 1: United States of America and Canada; Region 2: Germany, Ireland, and Finland; and Region 3: Italy; based on geographical similarities among these populations. The following statistically significant results were described in PD patients, compared with non-PD controls. In the first region, a significant increase in the following bacteria was seen: 1. Phylum: Actinobacteriota and its Genus: ; 2. Phylum: Verrucomicrobiota and its Genus: ; 3. Genus: , , , and of the Phylum: Firmicutes; 4. Family: of Phylum: Firmicutes; 5. Phylum: Bacteroidetes and its Genus: ; 6. Phylum: Proteobacteria. A significant decrease was described in the Family: and its Genus: , , and , which belong to the Phylum: Firmicutes. In the second region, a raised number of: 1. Phylum: Verrucomicrobiota, its Genus: , and its Species: ; 2. Family: of the Phylum: Verrucomicrobiota; 3. Genus: and of the Phylum: Firmicutes; 4. Family: of the Phylum: Firmicutes; 5. Family: of the Phylum: Bacteroidetes; 6. Genus: of the Phylum: Actinobacteriota; 7. Species: of the Phylum: Thermodesulfobacteriota, was identified. Only one Genus: of the Phylum: Bacteroidetes was decreased. In the third and last region, an augmented number of these bacteria were found: 1. Phylum: Verrucomicrobiota and its Genus: ; 2. Family: and of the Phylum: Actinobacteriota; 3. Phylum: Firmicutes and its Family: and ; 4. Family: and its Genus: , of the Phylum: Firmicutes; 5. Genus: and , of the Phylum: Firmicutes; 6. Phylum: Proteobacteria, its Family: , and the Genus: , , , and ; 7. Genus: of the Phylum: Bacteroidetes. In contrast, a significant decrease in 1. Phylum: Firmicutes, its Family: , and its Genus: and 2. Genus: of the Phylum: Firmicutes, was described. (4) Conclusion: A significant gut dysbiosis, involving multiple bacterial taxa, was found in PD patients compared to healthy people in the occidental regions. However, more studies are needed to find the precise pathophysiologic involvement of other groups of pathogens, such as fungi and parasites, in the development and progression of PD.
(1)背景:帕金森病(PD)是一种相对常见且复杂的病症,其部分机制仍有待阐明。宿主微生物群的变化与众多疾病的病理生理学相关。本系统评价旨在收集西半球的现有数据,进行比较,并探寻帕金森病与肠道微生物群失调之间的任何显著关联。(2)方法:本系统评价采用系统评价与Meta分析的首选报告项目(PRISMA)以及流行病学观察性研究的Meta分析(MOOSE)方案。使用PubMed作为数据库搜索引擎。在找到的166项研究中,仅10项被采用,因为它们符合我们的纳入标准:病例对照研究、评估PD与肠道微生物组相关性的研究、在西方地区开展的研究、针对人类进行的研究以及用英文撰写的研究。纽卡斯尔 - 渥太华量表被用作本系统评价中总体偏倚风险的评估工具。(3)结果:根据这些人群之间的地理相似性,所分析的研究被分为三个地理区域:区域1:美利坚合众国和加拿大;区域2:德国、爱尔兰和芬兰;区域3:意大利。与非PD对照相比,PD患者呈现出以下具有统计学意义的结果。在第一个区域,发现以下细菌显著增加:1. 门:放线菌门及其属: ;2. 门:疣微菌门及其属: ;3. 厚壁菌门的属: 、 、 、 ;4. 厚壁菌门的科: ;5. 门:拟杆菌门及其属: ;6. 门:变形菌门。属于厚壁菌门的科: 及其属: 、 、 显著减少。在第二个区域,发现数量增加的有:1. 门:疣微菌门、其属: 及其种: ;2. 疣微菌门的科: ;3. 厚壁菌门的属: 、 ;4. 厚壁菌门的科: ;5. 拟杆菌门的科: ;6. 放线菌门的属: ;7. 热脱硫杆菌门的种: 。仅拟杆菌门的一个属: 减少。在第三个也是最后一个区域,发现这些细菌数量增加:1. 门:疣微菌门及其属: ;2. 放线菌门的科: 、 ;3. 厚壁菌门及其科: 、 ;4. 厚壁菌门的科: 及其属: 、 ;5. 厚壁菌门的属: 和 ;6. 变形菌门、其科: 及其属: 、 、 、 ;7. 拟杆菌门的属: 。相比之下,描述了1.厚壁菌门、其科: 及其属: 和2. 厚壁菌门的属: 显著减少。(4)结论:与西方地区的健康人相比,PD患者存在显著的肠道微生物群失调,涉及多个细菌分类群。然而,需要更多研究来确定其他病原体组,如真菌和寄生虫,在PD发生和发展过程中的确切病理生理作用。