Department of Mathematics and Statistics, University of Wyoming, Laramie, USA.
Department of Mathematical and Computer Sciences, Indiana University of Pennsylvania, Indiana, USA.
Sci Total Environ. 2023 Nov 1;897:165105. doi: 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2023.165105. Epub 2023 Jun 29.
Monitoring COVID-19 infection cases has been a singular focus of many policy makers and communities. However, direct monitoring through testing has become more onerous for a number of reasons, such as costs, delays, and personal choices. Wastewater-based epidemiology (WBE) has emerged as a viable tool for monitoring disease prevalence and dynamics to supplement direct monitoring. The objective of this study is to intelligently incorporate WBE information to nowcast and forecast new weekly COVID-19 cases and to assess the efficacy of such WBE information for these tasks in an interpretable manner. The methodology consists of a time-series based machine learning (TSML) strategy that can extract deeper knowledge and insights from temporal structured WBE data in the presence of other relevant temporal variables, such as minimum ambient temperature and water temperature, to boost the capability for predicting new weekly COVID-19 case numbers. The results confirm that feature engineering and machine learning can be utilized to enhance the performance and interpretability of WBE for COVID-19 monitoring, along with identifying the different recommended features to be applied for short-term and long-term nowcasting and short-term and long-term forecasting. The conclusion of this research is that the proposed time-series ML methodology performs as well, and sometimes better, than simple predictions that assume available and accurate COVID-19 case numbers from extensive monitoring and testing. Overall, this paper provides an insight into the prospects of machine learning based WBE to the researchers and decision-makers as well as public health practitioners for predicting and preparing the next wave of COVID-19 or the next pandemic.
监测 COVID-19 感染病例一直是许多政策制定者和社区的重点关注。然而,由于成本、延迟和个人选择等多种原因,直接通过检测进行监测变得更加繁重。基于污水的流行病学(WBE)已成为一种可行的工具,可用于监测疾病的流行率和动态,以补充直接监测。本研究的目的是智能地结合 WBE 信息,对新的每周 COVID-19 病例进行实时预测和预测,并以可解释的方式评估这种 WBE 信息在这些任务中的效果。该方法包括基于时间序列的机器学习(TSML)策略,该策略可以从时间结构化的 WBE 数据中提取更深层次的知识和见解,同时考虑其他相关的时间变量,如最低环境温度和水温,以提高预测新的每周 COVID-19 病例数的能力。结果证实,特征工程和机器学习可用于增强 WBE 对 COVID-19 监测的性能和可解释性,同时确定要应用于短期和长期实时预测以及短期和长期预测的不同推荐特征。本研究的结论是,所提出的时间序列 ML 方法的性能与简单预测一样好,有时甚至更好,简单预测假设从广泛的监测和测试中获得可用且准确的 COVID-19 病例数。总体而言,本文为研究人员、决策者以及公共卫生从业者提供了一个关于基于机器学习的 WBE 的前景,以预测和准备下一波 COVID-19 或下一次大流行。