Martinho Diogo V, Naughton Robert J, Faria Ana, Rebelo André, Sarmento Hugo
University of Coimbra, Research Unit for Sport and Physical Activity, Faculty of Sport Sciences and Physical Education, Coimbra, Portugal.
Polytechnic of Coimbra, Coimbra Health School, Dietetics and Nutrition, Coimbra, Portugal.
Biol Sport. 2023 Jul;40(3):787-804. doi: 10.5114/biolsport.2023.119986. Epub 2022 Nov 18.
Resting energy expenditure (REE) is often estimated in athletes using equations developed from the general population however, the application in athletic-specific populations is questionable. The aim of this systematic review was to compare measured REE and estimations of REE obtained from non-sport participants and athletes. Inclusion criteria met PICO criteria: population - participants involved in organized sport; intervention - resting energy expenditure was obtained by calorimetry; comparator - equations to estimate REE; outcomes - comparisons between measured REE and predicted REE. The search was conducted in Web of Science all databases, PubMed and Scopus. Comparisons between measured REE and predicted REE as well the potential models to estimate REE developed among athletes were summarized. Allowing for variation among studies, equations developed within general populations were not comparable to REE measured by calorimetry in athletes. Equations across athletic samples were obtained but, few studies tested their validity across independent samples of sport participants. Nevertheless, equations developed within athlete populations seem to be widely unused in sports nutrition literature and practice. De Lorenzo and ten Haaf equations appear to present an acceptable agreement with measured REE. Finally, equations used among adults should not be generalised for youth sport participants.
静息能量消耗(REE)通常是使用从普通人群中得出的公式来估算运动员的,但在特定运动员群体中的应用存在疑问。本系统评价的目的是比较非运动参与者和运动员的实测REE与REE估算值。纳入标准符合PICO标准:人群——参与有组织运动的参与者;干预——通过量热法获得静息能量消耗;对照——估算REE的公式;结果——实测REE与预测REE之间的比较。检索在Web of Science所有数据库、PubMed和Scopus中进行。总结了实测REE与预测REE之间的比较以及在运动员中开发的估算REE的潜在模型。考虑到研究之间的差异,普通人群中开发的公式与运动员通过量热法测得的REE不可比。获得了不同运动员样本的公式,但很少有研究在独立的运动参与者样本中检验其有效性。然而,运动员群体中开发的公式在运动营养文献和实践中似乎未得到广泛应用。德洛伦佐方程和滕哈夫方程似乎与实测REE有可接受的一致性。最后,成人中使用的公式不应推广到青少年运动参与者。