Ye Wei, Chen Xicheng, Li Pengpeng, Tao Yongjun, Wang Zhenyan, Gao Chengcheng, Cheng Jian, Li Fang, Yi Dali, Wei Zeliang, Yi Dong, Wu Yazhou
Department of Health Statistics, College of Preventive Medicine, Army Medical University, Chongqing, China.
Department of Neurology, Taizhou Municipal Hospital, Taizhou, Zhejiang, China.
Front Neurol. 2023 Jun 21;14:1158555. doi: 10.3389/fneur.2023.1158555. eCollection 2023.
Early stroke prognosis assessments are critical for decision-making regarding therapeutic intervention. We introduced the concepts of data combination, method integration, and algorithm parallelization, aiming to build an integrated deep learning model based on a combination of clinical and radiomics features and analyze its application value in prognosis prediction.
The research steps in this study include data source and feature extraction, data processing and feature fusion, model building and optimization, model training, and so on. Using data from 441 stroke patients, clinical and radiomics features were extracted, and feature selection was performed. Clinical, radiomics, and combined features were included to construct predictive models. We applied the concept of deep integration to the joint analysis of multiple deep learning methods, used a metaheuristic algorithm to improve the parameter search efficiency, and finally, developed an acute ischemic stroke (AIS) prognosis prediction method, namely, the optimized ensemble of deep learning (OEDL) method.
Among the clinical features, 17 features passed the correlation check. Among the radiomics features, 19 features were selected. In the comparison of the prediction performance of each method, the OEDL method based on the concept of ensemble optimization had the best classification performance. In the comparison to the predictive performance of each feature, the inclusion of the combined features resulted in better classification performance than that of the clinical and radiomics features. In the comparison to the prediction performance of each balanced method, SMOTEENN, which is based on a hybrid sampling method, achieved the best classification performance than that of the unbalanced, oversampled, and undersampled methods. The OEDL method with combined features and mixed sampling achieved the best classification performance, with 97.89, 95.74, 94.75, 94.03, and 94.35% for Macro-AUC, ACC, Macro-R, Macro-P, and Macro-F1, respectively, and achieved advanced performance in comparison with that of methods in previous studies.
The OEDL approach proposed herein could effectively achieve improved stroke prognosis prediction performance, the effect of using combined data modeling was significantly better than that of single clinical or radiomics feature models, and the proposed method had a better intervention guidance value. Our approach is beneficial for optimizing the early clinical intervention process and providing the necessary clinical decision support for personalized treatment.
早期卒中预后评估对于治疗干预的决策至关重要。我们引入了数据组合、方法集成和算法并行化的概念,旨在构建一个基于临床和影像组学特征组合的集成深度学习模型,并分析其在预后预测中的应用价值。
本研究的研究步骤包括数据来源与特征提取、数据处理与特征融合、模型构建与优化、模型训练等。利用441例卒中患者的数据,提取临床和影像组学特征,并进行特征选择。纳入临床、影像组学和组合特征来构建预测模型。我们将深度集成的概念应用于多种深度学习方法的联合分析,使用元启发式算法提高参数搜索效率,最终开发出一种急性缺血性卒中(AIS)预后预测方法,即优化集成深度学习(OEDL)方法。
在临床特征中,17个特征通过了相关性检验。在影像组学特征中,选择了19个特征。在各方法预测性能的比较中,基于集成优化概念的OEDL方法具有最佳的分类性能。在各特征预测性能的比较中,纳入组合特征后的分类性能优于临床和影像组学特征。在各平衡方法预测性能的比较中,基于混合采样方法的SMOTEENN比不平衡、过采样和欠采样方法具有最佳的分类性能。具有组合特征和混合采样的OEDL方法具有最佳的分类性能,Macro-AUC、ACC、Macro-R、Macro-P和Macro-F1分别为97.89%、95.74%、94.75%、94.03%和94.35%,与以往研究中的方法相比具有先进的性能。
本文提出的OEDL方法能够有效提高卒中预后预测性能,使用组合数据建模的效果明显优于单一临床或影像组学特征模型,且该方法具有更好的干预指导价值。我们的方法有利于优化早期临床干预过程,并为个性化治疗提供必要的临床决策支持。