Zhelenkova Antonina, Panichella Nazareno
Department of Social and Political Science, University of Milan, Milano, Italy.
Br J Sociol. 2023 Dec;74(5):808-816. doi: 10.1111/1468-4446.13045. Epub 2023 Jul 8.
The study examines the educational inequalities in upper secondary education in Italy, with a focus on the vertical dimension of school enrolment and the horizontal dimension of track and curriculum choice. To measure the importance of family background, we use the estimation of sibling correlations, which has seldom been used in the analysis of track choice in upper secondary education. Using data from the Italian Labor Force Survey 2005-2020 (ILFS), which includes detailed information on household characteristics such as the gender composition of siblings and parental education and occupational status, we find that around half of the variation in the probability of attending upper secondary school in Italy is related to the family of origin. We also show that comparing sibling correlations on binary outcomes should be complemented by additional statistics, such as variances at the individual and family levels and proportions of enrolled sibling pairs. For upper secondary school enrolment, advantaged families have a relatively lower sibling correlation due to minor variations at both individual and family levels. However, in terms of track choice, the sibling correlation is relatively higher for enrolment in the academic track compared to the technical and vocational tracks. Additionally, with respect to the attendance of science/technical curricula within each track, the results indicate a lower sibling correlation for the academic track than for the other two tracks, which suggests that individual characteristics have a greater impact than family background when these outcomes are considered.
该研究考察了意大利高中教育中的教育不平等现象,重点关注入学的纵向维度以及课程和轨道选择的横向维度。为衡量家庭背景的重要性,我们采用了兄弟姐妹相关性估计法,这种方法在高中教育轨道选择分析中很少被使用。利用2005 - 2020年意大利劳动力调查(ILFS)的数据,其中包括有关家庭特征的详细信息,如兄弟姐妹的性别构成、父母的教育程度和职业状况,我们发现意大利高中入学概率约一半的变化与家庭出身有关。我们还表明,比较二元结果上的兄弟姐妹相关性时,应辅以其他统计数据,如个体和家庭层面的方差以及入学兄弟姐妹对的比例。对于高中入学,优势家庭由于个体和家庭层面的微小差异,其兄弟姐妹相关性相对较低。然而,在轨道选择方面,与技术和职业轨道相比,学术轨道入学的兄弟姐妹相关性相对较高。此外,就各轨道内科学/技术课程的就读情况而言,结果表明学术轨道的兄弟姐妹相关性低于其他两个轨道,这表明在考虑这些结果时,个体特征比家庭背景的影响更大。