MRC/CSO Social and Public Health Sciences Unit, School of Health and Wellbeing, University of Glasgow, Glasgow, UK.
Centre for Health Policy, School of Social Work and Social Policy, University of Strathclyde, Glasgow, UK.
Health Expect. 2023 Dec;26(6):2264-2277. doi: 10.1111/hex.13825. Epub 2023 Jul 24.
It is increasingly recognised by UK researchers and population health advocates that an important impetus to effective policy action to address health inequalities is activation of public dialogue about the social determinants of health and how inequalities might be addressed. The limited body of existing scholarship reaches varying conclusions on public preferences for responding to health inequalities but with consensus around the importance of tackling poverty. Young people's perspectives remain underexplored despite their increasingly visible role in activism across a range of policy issues and the potential impact of widening inequalities on their generation's health and wellbeing.
Six groups of young people (39 in total) from two UK cities (Glasgow and Leeds) were engaged in online workshops to explore views on health inequalities and potential solutions. Inspired by calls to employ notions of utopia, artist-facilitators and researchers supported participants to explore the evidence, debating solutions and imagining a more desirable society, using visual and performance art. Drawing together data from discussions and creative outputs, we analysed participants' perspectives on addressing health inequalities across four domains: governance, environment, society/culture and economy.
Proposals ranged from radical, whole-systems change to support for policies currently being considered by governments across the United Kingdom. The consensus was built around embracing more participatory, collaborative governance; prioritising sustainability and access to greenspace; promoting inclusivity and eliminating discrimination and improving the circumstances of those on the lowest incomes. Levels of acceptable income inequality, and how best to address income inequality were more contested. Individual-level interventions were rarely presented as viable options for addressing the social inequalities from which health differences emanate.
Young people contributed wide-ranging and visionary solutions to debates around addressing the enduring existence of health inequalities in the United Kingdom. Their reflections signal support for 'upstream' systemic change to achieve reductions in social inequalities and the health differences that flow from these.
An advisory group of young people informed the development of project plans. Participants shaped the direction of the project in terms of substantive focus and were responsible for the generation of creative project outputs aimed at influencing policymakers.
英国研究人员和人口健康倡导者越来越认识到,推动解决健康不平等问题的有效政策行动的一个重要动力是激活公众对话,讨论健康的社会决定因素以及如何解决不平等问题。现有学术研究的有限内容对公众对解决健康不平等问题的偏好得出了不同的结论,但共识是解决贫困问题很重要。尽管年轻人在一系列政策问题的激进主义中越来越活跃,不平等问题的扩大对他们这一代人的健康和福祉可能产生的影响,他们的观点仍然没有得到充分的探索。
来自英国两个城市(格拉斯哥和利兹)的六组年轻人(共 39 人)参加了在线研讨会,探讨他们对健康不平等问题的看法和潜在解决方案。受探索乌托邦观念的呼吁的启发,艺术家主持人和研究人员支持参与者使用视觉和表演艺术来探讨证据、辩论解决方案并想象一个更理想的社会,从而探索治理、环境、社会/文化和经济四个领域解决健康不平等问题的办法。
建议范围从支持整个系统的变革,以支持英国各地政府正在考虑的政策,到支持目前正在考虑的政策。共识是围绕着采取更具参与性、协作性的治理方式;优先考虑可持续性和绿色空间的获取;促进包容性,消除歧视和改善低收入人群的生活条件。可接受的收入不平等水平以及解决收入不平等的最佳方式存在更多争议。个人层面的干预措施很少被视为解决健康差异产生的社会不平等的可行选择。
年轻人为解决英国持久存在的健康不平等问题的辩论贡献了广泛而富有远见的解决方案。他们的思考表明支持“上游”系统变革,以减少社会不平等和由此产生的健康差异。
一个由年轻人组成的咨询小组为项目计划的制定提供了信息。参与者在实质性重点方面塑造了项目的方向,并负责生成旨在影响政策制定者的创意项目成果。