Savas Sumru, Kilavuz Asli, Kayhan Koçak Fatma Özge, Cavdar Sibel
Division of Geriatrics, Department of Internal Medicine, School of Medicine, Ege University, Izmir 35100, Turkey.
J Clin Med. 2023 Jun 25;12(13):4260. doi: 10.3390/jcm12134260.
Grip strength (GS) is widely used in various fields such as sports, rehabilitation, and geriatrics to assess muscle strength, and to diagnose sarcopenia and frailty in older adults. There is a potential for measurement differences among different dynamometers available, and studies comparing GS measurements by variable tools have conflicting results. The two most frequently used dynamometers are the Jamar hydraulic (Jamar) and spring-type hand grip dynamometers, and Jamar has not been compared to Jamar PLUS+ Digital (Jamar+) dynamometer in older adults. So, we aimed to assess GS measurements with the Jamar as the reference standard against Jamar+, and spring-type Takei T.KK. 5401 (Takei) digital dynamometers. One hundred and ten outpatients aged >60 years were included. Inter-instrumental reliability was determined. The differences between dynamometers were evaluated by Bland-Altman plots and measurement error. The measurements with Jamar+, and Takei dynamometers were reliable and valid regarding the Jamar dynamometer. Takei and Jamar+ dynamometers overestimated GS over the Jamar dynamometer. Though the differences in the measured values might be disregarded in clinical practice, individuals defined to have low GS varied by the use of different dynamometers. Grip strength better be measured by the same dynamometer in serial measurements of older individuals.
握力(GS)在体育、康复和老年医学等各个领域被广泛用于评估肌肉力量,以及诊断老年人的肌肉减少症和虚弱。现有不同测力计之间存在测量差异的可能性,并且比较不同工具测量握力的研究结果相互矛盾。两种最常用的测力计是Jamar液压式(Jamar)和弹簧式手握测力计,在老年人中尚未将Jamar与Jamar PLUS+数字式(Jamar+)测力计进行比较。因此,我们旨在以Jamar作为参考标准,评估Jamar+和弹簧式竹内T.KK. 5401(Takei)数字测力计的握力测量情况。纳入了110名年龄大于60岁的门诊患者。确定了仪器间的可靠性。通过Bland-Altman图和测量误差评估测力计之间的差异。就Jamar测力计而言,Jamar+和Takei测力计的测量是可靠且有效的。Takei和Jamar+测力计测量的握力比Jamar测力计高估。尽管在临床实践中测量值的差异可能被忽略,但使用不同测力计定义为握力低的个体有所不同。在对老年人进行连续测量时,最好使用同一测力计测量握力。