Choi Heesun, Wray Alisa, Smart Jonathan
University of California Irvine, Department of Emergency Medicine, Orange, CA.
Kingman Regional Medical Center, Department of Emergency Medicine, Kingman, AZ.
J Educ Teach Emerg Med. 2022 Jul 15;7(3):SG1-SG23. doi: 10.21980/J8RM0M. eCollection 2022 Jul.
Targeted audience could be learners in medical field with basic knowledge of point-of-care ultrasound (POCUS), pulmonary and emergency medicine for example, medical students, emergency medicine residents (1-3 year), emergency physicians at all level of trainings, or emergency medicine physician's assistants.
Point-of-care ultrasound (POCUS) is rapidly becoming an essential part of emergency medicine and patient care .1,2 POCUS can provide more detailed clinical information when used in conjunction with a physical examination, overall aiding clinicians' decision-making capacity.3 POCUS also proves a cost-effective tool in reducing the number of advanced imaging studies ordered and unnecessary patient radiation exposure.3,4 Performing POCUS has also proved beneficial for patient satisfaction because it increases the amount of face-to-face time spent with the patient while also providing live imaging interpretation during the emergency department visits .3,5,6 POCUS-Pulmonary can also create a safer environment for both medical staff and patients during the COVID-19 pandemic.6 Performing POCUS-Pulmonary on suspected COVID-19 patients can limit the number of patients receiving thoracic CT studies to confirm COVID-19 related pneumonia.6,7 Performing POCUS-Pulmonary reduces the number of patients transferred between the radiology department and the emergency department, significantly reduces overall possible COVID-19 exposures, and reduces equipment cleaning time.6 Given the overall reduction of advanced imaging studies ordered, CT scanners would be more readily available for critical care patients, such as trauma or other hemodynamic instability.6 Emergency providers practicing in rural areas with limited resources may benefit from the use of POCUS -Pulmonary, facilitating better patient care at decreased exposure-rate, cleaning cost, and overall increase in patient satisfaction given more bedside patient-provider communication.6-8 POCUS-Pulmonary is a crucial clinical skill for emergency medicine providers everywhere.6,8 Clinicians should be able to perform POCUS-Pulmonary, interpret image findings, and develop a treatment plan promptly.9.
By the end of performing the Zombie Cruise Ship Virtual Escape Room, learners will be able to: 1) recognize sonographic signs of A-line, B-line, Barcode sign, Bat sign, Seashore Sign, Plankton sign, Jellyfish Sign, Lung point, lung lockets, and Lung pulse; 2) differentiate sonographic findings of pneumothorax, hemothorax, pneumonia, COVID 19 pneumonia, pulmonary edema, and pleural effusion from normal lung findings; 3) distinguish pneumonia from atelectasis by recognizing dynamic air bronchogram; and 4) recognize indications for performing POCUS pulmonary such as dyspnea, blunt trauma, fall, cough and/or heart failure.
This group-based learning program was designed for use in virtual meetings, lectures, and in small-group learning activities, such as didactic and EM conferences. A Google form was used to create a virtual escape room for learners in which they had to take quizzes to advance to the next level. Learners may enact teamwork through discussion and group effort, or respond individually to ultrasound pulmonary questions.
Learners will take pre and post-test assessment to compare the learners POCUS-Pulmonary knowledge before and after small group, virtual escape room learning. All participants in the virtual escape room game are given a pre and post-test assessment comprised of seventeen total questions: two questions asking the participant's training level, and fifteen POCUS-Pulmonary questions. Pre and Post-test questions are identical; however, the participants' answers to the pre-test assessment are not revealed to them on completion. Instead, participants receive a letter grade on completing the pre-test assessment. Participants complete the pre and post-test assessments over fifteen minutes allotted before and after the virtual escape room. Upon completing the post-test assessment, a letter grade and the correct answers were given to the participants.
Twenty-four emergency medicine resident physicians (PGY 1-3)) participated in the Zombie Cruise Ship Escape Room pre-test, while a total of twenty-three resident physicians participated in the post-test assessment. The pre-test data showed an average of 10.33 points, compared to post-test data, which showed 11.91 points. There was an improvement of two points on the median score with a median pre-test score of 10 vs. the post-test median of 12.
The virtual zombie cruise ship experience proved a practical and useful tool in increasing overall participants' interest in POCUS pulmonary during the COVID-19 pandemic. Participants had higher retention after actively discussing and researching the most up-to-date clinical information during the virtual and inperson small group meetings. The game encouraged participants to make decisions quickly. This pace created a fun competition between participants who genuinely enjoyed the learning experience even during the COVID-19 pandemic via Zoom/Google Meet virtual conferences. By creating a virtual escape learning tool, learners can experience teamwork-based learning without concern for group size limitations during the pandemic.
Sonographic findings of pneumothorax, hemothorax, pneumonia, COVID-19 pneumonia, pulmonary edema, pleural effusion, normal lung, A-line, lack of A-line, presence of B-line, Lung sliding, M mode, dynamic air bronchogram, lung rockets, Bar code Sign, Bat Sign, lung pulse, lung point, hepatization, Seashore Sign, Plankton Sign, Jellyfish Sign, and subpleural pulmonary consolidation.
目标受众可以是具有床旁超声(POCUS)基础知识的医学领域学习者,例如肺科和急诊科医学专业的学生、急诊医学住院医师(1 - 3年)、各级培训阶段的急诊医生,或急诊医学医师助理。
床旁超声(POCUS)正迅速成为急诊医学和患者护理的重要组成部分。1,2 POCUS与体格检查结合使用时,可提供更详细的临床信息,总体上有助于临床医生的决策能力。3 POCUS还被证明是一种具有成本效益的工具,可减少所开具的高级影像学检查数量以及患者不必要的辐射暴露。3,4 进行POCUS检查对患者满意度也有益,因为它增加了与患者面对面交流的时间,同时在急诊科就诊期间提供实时影像解读。3,5,6 在新冠疫情期间,肺部POCUS还可为医护人员和患者创造更安全的环境。6 对疑似新冠患者进行肺部POCUS检查可减少接受胸部CT检查以确诊新冠相关肺炎的患者数量。6,7 进行肺部POCUS检查可减少在放射科和急诊科之间转运的患者数量,显著减少总体可能的新冠暴露,并减少设备清洁时间。6 鉴于所开具的高级影像学检查总体减少,CT扫描仪将更便于用于重症患者,如创伤或其他血流动力学不稳定患者。6 在资源有限的农村地区执业的急诊医疗服务提供者可能会从使用肺部POCUS中受益,在降低暴露率、清洁成本的情况下促进更好的患者护理,并通过更多的床边医患交流总体提高患者满意度。6 - 8 肺部POCUS对各地的急诊医学提供者而言是一项关键的临床技能。6,8 临床医生应能够进行肺部POCUS检查、解读影像结果并迅速制定治疗方案。9
在完成“僵尸游轮虚拟密室逃脱”后,学习者将能够:1)识别A线、B线、条形码征、蝙蝠征、海岸征、浮游生物征、水母征、肺点、肺锁、肺搏动的超声征象;2)区分气胸、血胸、肺炎、新冠肺炎、肺水肿和胸腔积液的超声表现与正常肺部表现;3)通过识别动态空气支气管征来区分肺炎和肺不张;以及4)识别进行肺部POCUS检查的适应证,如呼吸困难、钝性创伤、跌倒、咳嗽和/或心力衰竭。
这个基于小组的学习项目设计用于虚拟会议、讲座以及小组学习活动,如理论教学和急诊医学会议。使用谷歌表单为学习者创建一个虚拟密室逃脱,他们必须通过答题才能进入下一关。学习者可以通过讨论和团队协作来完成,也可以单独回答肺部超声问题。
学习者将进行课前和课后评估,以比较在小组虚拟密室逃脱学习前后学习者对肺部POCUS的知识掌握情况。虚拟密室逃脱游戏的所有参与者都要进行课前和课后评估,总共包括17个问题:两个问题询问参与者的培训水平,以及15个肺部POCUS问题。课前和课后问题相同;然而,参与者在完成课前评估后不会看到自己的答案。相反,参与者在完成课前评估后会收到一个字母等级。参与者在虚拟密室逃脱前后各有15分钟时间完成课前和课后评估。完成课后评估后,会给参与者提供字母等级和正确答案。
24名急诊医学住院医师(PGY 1 - 3)参加了“僵尸游轮逃脱”的课前测试,共有23名住院医师参加了课后评估。课前测试数据显示平均得分为10.33分,相比之下,课后数据显示为11.91分。中位数得分提高了2分,课前中位数得分为10分,课后中位数为12分。
在新冠疫情期间,虚拟僵尸游轮体验被证明是提高参与者对肺部POCUS总体兴趣的实用且有用的工具。在虚拟和面对面的小组会议中积极讨论和研究最新临床信息后,参与者的记忆保持效果更好。该游戏鼓励参与者快速做出决策。这种节奏在参与者之间营造了一场有趣的竞争,即使在通过Zoom/Google Meet虚拟会议的新冠疫情期间,他们也真正享受了学习体验。通过创建一个虚拟逃脱学习工具,学习者可以体验基于团队的学习,而无需担心疫情期间小组规模的限制。
气胸、血胸、肺炎、新冠肺炎、肺水肿、胸腔积液、正常肺、A线、A线缺失、B线出现、肺滑动、M模式、动态空气支气管征、肺火箭征、条形码征、蝙蝠征、肺搏动、肺点、肝样变、海岸征、浮游生物征、水母征以及胸膜下肺实变的超声表现