Meehan Ashley A, Cox Sarah N, Thuo Nicholas B, Rogers Julia H, Link Amy C, Martinez Miguel A, Lo Natalie K, Manns Brian J, Rolfes Melissa A, Chow Eric J, Chu Helen Y, Mosites Emily, Al Achkar Morhaf
COVID-19 Emergency Response, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Atlanta, GA.
Department of Epidemiology, University of Washington, Seattle, WA.
J Patient Cent Res Rev. 2023 Jul 18;10(3):111-120. doi: 10.17294/2330-0698.2012. eCollection 2023 Summer.
The study purpose was to learn and describe 1) where homeless shelter residents receive health care, 2) what contributes to positive or negative health care experiences among shelter residents, and 3) shelter resident perceptions toward health care.
Semi-structured interviews (SSIs) utilizing purposive sampling and focus group discussions (FGDs) utilizing convenience sampling were conducted at 6 homeless shelters in Seattle-King County, Washington, during July-October 2021. All residents (age ≥18) were eligible to participate. SSIs were conducted with 25 residents, and 8 FGDs were held. Thematic analysis was conducted using Dedoose.
Participants received health care in settings ranging from no regular care to primary care providers. Four elements emerged as contributing positively and negatively to health care experiences: 1) ability to access health care financially, physically, and technologically; 2) clarity of communication from providers and staff about appointment logistics, diagnoses, and treatment options; 3) ease of securing timely follow-up services; and 4) respect versus stigma and discrimination from providers and staff. Participants who felt positively toward health care found low- or no-cost care to be widely available and encouraged others to seek care. However, some participants described health care in the United States as greedy, classist, discriminatory, and untrustworthy. Participants reported delaying care and self-medicating in anticipation of discrimination.
Findings demonstrate that while people experiencing homelessness can have positive experiences with health care, many have faced negative interactions with health systems. Improving the patient experience for those experiencing homelessness can increase engagement and improve health outcomes.
本研究旨在了解并描述:1)无家可归者收容所居民接受医疗保健的地点;2)哪些因素促成了收容所居民积极或消极的医疗保健体验;3)收容所居民对医疗保健的看法。
2021年7月至10月期间,在华盛顿州西雅图-金县的6个无家可归者收容所进行了采用目的抽样的半结构式访谈(SSIs)和采用便利抽样的焦点小组讨论(FGDs)。所有年龄≥18岁的居民均有资格参与。对25名居民进行了半结构式访谈,并举行了8次焦点小组讨论。使用Dedoose进行主题分析。
参与者接受医疗保健的场所各不相同,从没有常规护理到初级保健提供者。有四个因素对医疗保健体验产生了积极和消极的影响:1)在经济、身体和技术方面获得医疗保健的能力;2)提供者和工作人员在预约安排、诊断和治疗选择方面沟通的清晰度;3)获得及时后续服务的难易程度;4)提供者和工作人员给予的尊重与污名化及歧视。对医疗保健持积极态度的参与者发现低成本或免费医疗服务普遍可得,并鼓励其他人寻求医疗服务。然而,一些参与者将美国的医疗保健描述为贪婪、阶级主义、歧视性和不可信赖的。参与者报告称,由于预期会受到歧视,他们推迟了就医并自行用药。
研究结果表明,虽然无家可归者在医疗保健方面可能有积极的体验,但许多人在与医疗系统的互动中面临负面情况。改善无家可归者的就医体验可以提高他们的参与度并改善健康结果。