Department of Pediatric Dentistry and Orthodontics, School of Dentistry, Universidade Federal do Rio de Janeiro, Rio de Janeiro, RJ, Brazil.
Post-Graduation Program in Dentistry, School of Dentistry, Universidade Federal Do Rio de Janeiro, Rio de Janeiro, RJ, Brazil.
Eur Arch Paediatr Dent. 2023 Oct;24(5):585-590. doi: 10.1007/s40368-023-00822-1. Epub 2023 Jul 28.
To evaluate the reliability of YouTube™ videos on zirconia crowns in pediatric dentistry.
On January 4, 2022, a search was performed using the term "pediatric zirconia crown". The first 100 videos on the subject were included. Non-English videos, duplicates, and off-topic videos were excluded. For each video, an examiner recorded the number of views, likes, comments, channel followers, upload date, duration, and category rating. Two examiners assessed the reliability of the information presented in the videos using DISCERN, a brief questionnaire and scale score used to assess in a valid and reliable way the quality of information on treatment choices for health problems. Descriptive and inferential analyses were performed (p < 0.05).
Of the initial 100 videos, 72 were excluded because of language, duplication, and subject matter. The 28 remaining videos had an average of 3.5 comments, 8,896.18 channel followers, 5,614.00 views, 19.14 likes, and a duration of 840.32 s. The average view rate was 7.54 per day ± 10,206.81. There was a statistically significant difference between the number of views and comments (p < 0.001), likes and comments (p < 0.001), and likes and views (p = 0.006). According to the DISCERN, none of the videos received the maximum grade to be considered very good. Two were considered good, nine fair, fourteen poor, and three very poor.
Given that the majority of YouTube™ videos currently available on zirconia crowns in pediatric dentistry were deemed unreliable according to the DISCERN questionnaire, caution should be exercised when using the information presented.
评估 YouTube™ 视频中关于儿童牙科氧化锆牙冠的可靠性。
于 2022 年 1 月 4 日,使用术语“儿科氧化锆牙冠”进行搜索。纳入前 100 个主题视频。排除非英语视频、重复视频和主题不相关视频。对于每个视频,一位检查者记录观看次数、点赞数、评论数、频道关注者数量、上传日期、时长和类别评分。两位检查者使用 DISCERN(一种用于评估健康问题治疗选择信息质量的有效和可靠的简短问卷和量表评分)评估视频中呈现信息的可靠性。进行描述性和推断性分析(p<0.05)。
最初的 100 个视频中,有 72 个因语言、重复和主题被排除。其余 28 个视频的平均评论数为 3.5 条,频道关注者数量为 8896.18 人,观看次数为 5614.00 次,点赞数为 19.14 次,时长为 840.32 秒。平均观看率为每天 7.54 次±10206.81 次。观看次数和评论数(p<0.001)、点赞数和评论数(p<0.001)以及点赞数和观看次数(p=0.006)之间存在统计学差异。根据 DISCERN,没有一个视频获得满分,被认为是非常好的。两个被认为是好的,九个是中等的,十四个是差的,三个是非常差的。
根据 DISCERN 问卷,目前大多数关于儿童牙科氧化锆牙冠的 YouTube™ 视频被认为是不可靠的,因此在使用呈现的信息时应谨慎。