Psychiatry, University of Rochester School of Medicine and Dentistry, Rochester, New York, USA
Psychiatry, University of Rochester School of Medicine and Dentistry, Rochester, New York, USA.
Inj Prev. 2023 Oct;29(5):442-445. doi: 10.1136/ip-2023-044944. Epub 2023 Jul 28.
Universal interventions are key to reducing youth suicide rates, yet no universal intervention has demonstrated reduction in suicide mortality through an RCT. This study pooled three cluster-RCTs of (n=78 high schools), a universal social network-informed intervention. In each trial, matched pairs of schools were assigned to immediate intervention or wait-list. Six schools were assigned without a pair due to logistical constraints. During the study period, no suicides occurred in intervention schools vs four in control schools, that is, suicide rates of 0 vs. 20.86/100,000, respectively. Results varied across statistical tests of impact. A state-level exact test pooling all available schools showed fewer suicides in intervention vs. control schools (p=0.047); whereas a stricter test involving only schools with a randomised pair found no difference (p=0.150). Results suggest that identifying mortality-reducing interventions will require commitment to new public-health designs optimised for population-level interventions, including adaptive roll-out trials.
普遍干预措施是降低青年自杀率的关键,但尚无普遍干预措施通过随机对照试验证明可降低自杀死亡率。本研究汇集了三项(n=78 所高中)的整群随机对照试验,这是一项普遍的基于社交网络的干预措施。在每项试验中,配对的学校被随机分配到立即干预组或等待名单组。由于后勤限制,有六所学校没有配对。在研究期间,干预组的学校没有发生自杀事件,而对照组的学校则发生了四起自杀事件,自杀率分别为 0 与 20.86/100,000。结果在影响的统计检验中存在差异。一项州级的精确检验显示,干预组的自杀人数少于对照组(p=0.047);而一项更严格的检验,仅涉及有随机配对的学校,则没有发现差异(p=0.150)。结果表明,确定可降低死亡率的干预措施将需要致力于新的公共卫生设计,这些设计针对人群干预措施进行了优化,包括适应性推广试验。